Jones guilty of starving man to death: Jury convicts on second-degree murder charges
|
The six-man, six-woman jury returned with the verdict following two hours of deliberation, capping the three-day trial. Jones seemed unsurprised by the announcement, later choking back tears as she said good-bye to family members as she was being led back to jail.
“We did the best we could do, Doreen,” Public Defender Dan Bryant told his client as she was being shackled following the trial.
“I know,” she responded, as she briefly made eye-contact with her attorney.
The conviction came after jurors were bombarded with graphic pictures and evidence and even the words of the defendant herself, which were captured on video tape during an interview shortly after her arrest last year.
“This trial was hard emotionally on the jury,” said District Attorney General Dale Potter. “Some of them will remember what they saw here for the rest of their lives. We appreciate their work because this was something that was very difficult to see.”
The graphic nature included the display of photos of the victim, showing him at 81 pounds when he was admitted to the hospital – just one week before his death in October, 2001. Doctors testified he died from a combination of malnutrition, hypothermia and dehydration, with pneumonia being a secondary cause of death.
The prosecution’s contention was Jones took Anderson into her care after his former boarding home closed down. Potter maintained Jones took Anderson so she could have his Social Security check. Prosecutors then maintain she used the money to buy alcohol and spend on herself, often leaving Anderson without the essentials to sustain life.
Proof was also admitted that Jones would often leave Anderson alone in their apartment, locked inside a room with no food or bathroom facilities.
For the defense, Bryant questioned why Jones would want Anderson to die since that would mean the end of his Social Security check. The defense, using Forensic Pathologist Dr. Charles Harlan, tried to convince the jury that Anderson was simply in poor health and that his body had worn out since he was old beyond his age of 67.
“People age differently,” Harlan testified, noting the multiple bruises found on Anderson’s body could have been caused easily and by a number of reasons given his fragile condition and did not necessarily mean he was abused physically. “People’s bodies just wear out.”
Disturbing prosecutors was the testimony of Anderson’s doctor, Dr. Joseph Caten, who said no signs of abuse were found when he was examined three months before his death.
However, Adult Protect Services Investigator Lisa Gribble argued for the prosecution that she felt something was wrong when she was called in to look into the case in June.
During a talk with Anderson, Gribble said he had told her of his bruises, “Doreen hit me.”
“There was pure terror in his eyes,” Gribble said. “I’ll always remember the terror I saw.”
However, without his physician making a referral, Gribble said she was forced to close the case.
For the defense, Anderson’s mental care expert, April Rummage, said she doubted Anderson could have communicated anything to Gribble given his schizophrenia.
“He was simply incapable of effective communication,” Rummage said, noting she had seen him in March for the last time. She said he did not appear to have been abused at that time, although prosecutors pointed out things could have changed in the five months before his death.
Perhaps playing heavily against her was Jones’ own words, captured on video tape during an interview with police the day after her arrest.
On the tape, Jones told several different versions of her story, often growing angry at her questioners.
“This is a bunch of s%$#,” Jones is heard telling police.
During questioning, Jones first told lawmen she gave Anderson three square meals a day.
“I fed him every day,” Jones told police at the beginning of the interview.
Later, she admitted, sometimes, due to shortage of money, she was only able to give him a little something each day.
“I fed him the best I could,” Jones said midway through the interview.
By the end of the video-taped interview, Jones had backed off even more, saying there may have been gaps in the feedings, and days when even she went hungry.
Adding to her admissions were witnesses who said they saw Anderson inside an apartment office where he lived, eating candy bars like a ravenous man one day when he wandered off from his care-giver. In addition, an ICU nurse said he thought Anderson “would swallow the spoon” when he was feeding him pudding after he was admitted to the hospital just before his death.
Potter, and assistant prosecutor Larry Bryant, pointed out often through the trial that the dramatic loss of weight was something that anyone would notice, telling jurors to use their common sense when deciding what really happened.
“I’m not surprised,” said Bryant of the conviction. “It was just too bad of a situation. I think the jury was very attentive and I appreciate that.”
The conviction means Jones faces 15 to 25 years in prison. She will be sentenced April 25 by Judge Bart Stanley.
