Skip to content

The Scoop: Footage shows frisky dog killed by police

I’d almost forgotten about the Cookeville police officers who pulled over the innocent family, handcuffed them on the side of Interstate 40, and then shot their dog.

I had almost forgotten until video footage of the traffic stop, and the dog shooting, was released Wednesday. The footage was recorded from a Tennessee Highway Patrol car after the highway patrol came to the aid of three Cookeville officers who had pulled over the family, riding through Tennessee only to return from vacation to their North Carolina home.

Based on dispatcher reporters, officers suspected the car, a green station wagon, was connected to a Nashville robbery. Never mind the fact there had not been a Nashville robbery that day. Forget that the person who made the 911 call didn’t have a clue as to what had actually happened.

With guns drawn, officers ordered driver James Smoak, his wife, and his 17-year-old son out of the car. It was while the Smoaks were handcuffed that their dog jumped from the car and was killed 3 seconds later.

There has been some discussion as to whether the officer was justified in shooting the dog — a bulldog/ boxer mix that probably stood a foot tall and might have weighed 35 pounds. This comes after the statement from the officer, Eric Hall, who contends he was forced to shoot the dog in self-defense.

My response is if this officer is afraid of what amounts to a lap dog, he needs to find a different line of work. He’s not a man. He’s a cowardly little boy.

The video footage clearly shows a small dog bouncing from the family’s station wagon with its tail wagging. The dog was darting around in a frisky, playful manner, probably expecting to give chase to a nearby tennis ball when he was shot.

If nothing else, I have to applaud the loyalty of the highway patrol. Even though it’s blatantly obvious Eric Hall has no business with his hand on a shotgun trigger, the highway patrol provided its full support.

In a statement, the highway patrol said its investigation revealed the situation was handled appropriately and that officer Hall “acted accordingly” when killing the dog.

Truth be told, I’m glad the officer shot the dog — and not one of the family members. Keep in mind, this was just a normal family traveling down the interstate when officers harassed and handcuffed them at gun point.

It’s painfully reminiscent of the case in Lebanon about a year ago when police there stormed the wrong house with an arrest warrant. The middle-aged couple inside the home didn’t know who was breaking down their door so the man got his gun and fired. As a result, police fired back and killed a man who was guilty of sitting on his sofa and watching TV. It turns out, police were supposed to raid the house next door.

One of the things that disturbs me the most is these incidents have taken place right here in the Midstate. We’re not talking about Nebraska or Wyoming or someplace none of us ever visit. It could have been me and my wife driving through Cookeville for that matter.

I realize being a law enforcement officer is a tough, often thankless, job. And I truly believe our officers aren’t paid nearly what they’re worth. When lawyers live in mansions and our police officers are just scraping by, there is something seriously wrong with our judicial system.

I also understand it’s no picnic walking up to an unfamiliar vehicle at night. I certainly wouldn’t want that job.

At the same time, the people who do have that job need to have a lick of sense. And if those officers honestly believed they had just pulled over hardened criminals, cleverly disguised as a family of three, they don’t need a gun or a badge.

(James Clark is editor of the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].)

Leave a Comment