Skip to content

Media Musings: Few Hispanics are in the media

Diversity in news coverage cannot become a reality until newsrooms become diversified. And, in many news organizations, the staff is white only.

That’s why the report that the booming Hispanic population is almost invisible in the news reports of the major TV networks and CNN is not a stunning revelation but a reaffirmation the problem is as bad today as it was last year.

According to the National Association of Hispanic Journalists, the research it commissioned found only 0.62 percent were about Hispanics and of that tiny percentage the story of the U.S. military exercises on the Puerto Rican island of Vieques dominated.

It’s fair to ask why this matters to the reader or viewer and the answer is found in the demographics of the nation. Today, there are more than 35 million Hispanics and their numbers increased 60 percent since 1990.

One of the most important roles played by news organizations is the sharing of the lives of one group of Americans with the rest, an electronic bridge that helps us to not only govern, but also to better understand the complexities inside a nation of all races, religions, and creeds.

This bridging effect, over time, can help build better understanding, hopefully, of the gifts, problems, hopes and dreams diversity brings. A recent think tank study reported the economic boom of the 1900s would never have been possible without the second greatest wave of immigration in our history.

Juan Gonzalez couldn’t have summarized the problem better than this: “The networks’ dismal record of covering the nation’s fastest-growing minority group undermines the information needs of all U.S. residents and distorts the public discourse so necessary for any democratic society.”

ABC answered the charge by pointing out it has just hired two Hispanic correspondents. NBC had a more solid footing, pointing out it now owns a major Spanish language network, Telemundo, and it was being integrated into NBC News. But it’s really difficult to be impressed by the hiring of a handful of correspondents. CNN and CBS have yet to respond.

The problem for TV news is not that it is racist or angry or trying to avoid doing stories about the entire nation. Rather, it’s an old mindset about what is and what is not newsworthy. Old and tired definitions haunt not only the networks but local television as well. When you consider that major local and national newscasts count every story by the clock, the compression eliminates stories that have subtlety, shading and nuance.

The missed opportunities are blatant. Take “Dateline NBC.” How many crime stories can their producers in “exclusive” arrangement with “Court TV” run a year? How many Monday Mysteries can “48 Hours” run on Monday night? We’re soaking in crime because it’s easy to cover, cheap, and violent. It’s also boring.

To those who wonder why Hispanics and people of color must become part of news organizations, there is one compelling argument: White people don’t have the language and cultural understanding, often, to do excellent, incisive reporting. Do you really want to send a white reporter with the ability to speak only English into the barrio to get an honest fair report? Of course not.

But a news definition that drops the tired approaches along with the development of a diversified workforce would go a long way to ending the kind of report we got this week about Hispanic coverage.

(Ed Kimbrell is a professor in MTSU’s School of Journalism.)

Leave a Comment