Voice of Reason: Our health care is badly lacking
Philosopher and educator Eli Siegel once asked, “What does a person deserve by being a person?” How about one’s health? Is quality health care something everybody deserves or is it something deserved only by those who can afford it?
While not directly related, the current contract squabble between River Park Hospital and Blue Cross/Blue Shield got me to pondering the extent to which the profit motive has perverted this country’s health care system and the changes which must be drastically made to it if, indeed, we do want a system that is fair and just to all.
The way our health care system is structured now is fairly simple. If you have money, your health, and therefore your life, has value and if you do not, it doesn’t.
Consider this: in ours, the wealthiest nation the earth has ever seen, there are over 45 million people with no health insurance at all. Can you imagine living with this kind of fear, where a minor illness or accident can mean economic disaster. And preventative medicine like a physical checkup or a blood test for these 45 million? Forget it – it’s an unaffordable luxury.
Added to these are many of the 200 million people counted among the insured who are in fact under-insured. These are the people with very limited policies which cover only catastrophic injuries, include exclusions for a long list of health problems and require large co-payments, the latter of which often discourages low- and middle-income families from seeking medical help when needed.
Why should anyone be forced to choose between using what little money is available for either food and rent, or for health care and medicine? The answer is we shouldn’t, and as the world’s richest country we can do a much better job in seeing that we don’t have to.
At 14 percent of its gross domestic product, the United States spends more per capita on health care than any other nation in the world. Ironically, the World Health Organization ranks the U.S. as only 37th in overall quality of health care.
What gives? Try much of our health care spending going toward insurance company overhead, unnecessary (read padded or fraudulent) billing and administrative costs, obscene profits, and inflated executive salaries at large HMOs and other health care companies.
The underlying problem with this country’s health care system is that it is for-profit. The idea that those in the heath care industry (which includes not just hospitals and insurance companies, but pharmaceutical companies as well) have as their purpose to make money from people’s ill health and misery is obscene. The fact they feel they can charge whatever makes for larger and larger profits from said misery is disgusting. It’s profiteering and nothing less.
The solution to this problem, which is hurting more and more people every day, must be a non-profit universal health care system. From cradle to nursing home, we need a single payer (funded by the federal government) system with choice which is accessible, affordable, with quality care which focuses on preventative medicine.
Additionally, the system would need to cover the large gaps found in most private plans today, like coverage for prescription drugs and medical supplies, dental, vision and hearing care, long-term care, mental health care, and treatment for substance abuse.
The Canadians and Europeans figured out how to implement a plan such as this 30 years and 50 years ago, respectively. If they can do it (at less than we’re currently paying for inadequate private health care), so can we.
(Will Stewart is a reporter for the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].)
