Skip to content

Supreme Court overturns verdicts in two local cases: Says Haston didn’t have authority to let McGregor hear cases

Supreme Court overturns verdicts in two local cases: Says Haston didn't have authority to let McGregor hear cases

MC GREGOR
A pair of local worker’s compensation cases have been struck down by the Tennessee Supreme Court with the justices finding the court acted inappropriately in making its decisions.

“We hold that the trial judge failed to perform all the duties of the judge’s office prescribed by law in these cases by improperly delegating his authority to the clerk and master to adjudicate the cases,” wrote Justice Janice M. Holder in reversing the court’s ruling and directing the cases be brought back before the court.

The reversal came in connection with a pair of workplace injury cases, one filed by Linda S. Reece against Findlay Industries, and the other filed by Harold Edward Tigue against Tokio Marine & Fire Insurance Company.

At the heart of the successful appeals were orders signed by former Circuit Court Judge Charles Haston, which the Supreme Court did not feel fit the content of his handwritten trial notes.

Specifically, the Supreme Court found that Clerk and Master Richard McGregor had been appointed to hear the cases; however, that Haston had actually presided in court to hear evidence in the cases. The case records were then turned over to McGregor, the Supreme Court found, and an order and ruling on the cases were drafted by the clerk and master and sent to Haston for his signature.

When quizzed about the unusual orders, Haston told the court he may have signed the orders without looking at them given the volume of paper work which crossed his desk on an average day.

“I make no bones about the fact, if an order is put in front with me with a blank line on it, I’ll sign it,” Haston told the court. “That’s bad business, but I sign so many.”

In reversing the ruling in the cases, the Supreme Court pointed to an earlier reversal of a local worker’s compensation case where McGregor had been appointed by Haston to be special chancellor. The court noted its earlier decision should have made it clear the clerk and master (or any special judge) could only be appointed to hear a case in the place of the regular judge only if the judge was absent. The court added such appointments could not be made purely for the convenience of the court.

Haston, who retired in the middle of his term this May, candidly admitted one of the major reasons for his early departure was the Supreme Court’s earlier ruling that the clerk and master could not be used to help handle the worker’s compensation docket

With the court’s ruling, a stern warning was passed down by the justices, spelling out there will be future reversals of local verdicts should a special judge be appointed in cases not specifically allowed by the law.

Leave a Comment