Skip to content

Evidence of Sedberry Hotel still remains downtown

Evidence of Sedberry Hotel still remains downtown

The watercolor of the famous Sedberry Hotel by local artist Monte Wanamaker, pictured above, clearly shows the “Sedberry Hotel” sign painted on the wall. (Charles W. Johnson photo)
If you walk down the alleyway between the old Park Theater and Cumberland Bank you may notice a old sign painted on ancient brick framed with new brick work.

The sign says simply: hotel.

You may wonder why the contractors working on the renovation around the Park Theater decided to preserve that obscure bit of signage. It does seem exceedingly odd.

Odd, that is, until you ask around and find out the lettering is part of the sign from the Sedberry Hotel, one of the premier establishments in the Midsouth in the early 1900s, playing host to many of the era’s celebrities and foreign dignitaries, reportedly including a nephew of the Czar of Russia, politicians Huey Long and Cordell Hull, gangster Al Capone and baseball great Babe Ruth, all of whom either stayed or dined at the Sedberry.

County historian J.A. Dillon remembers the Sedberry well.

“It was known from coast to coast,” said Dillon. “It was very famous. Anyone over 50 would remember the Sedberry.”

According to Dillon, the building on that corner near Court Square has gone through several transitions in its history. Originally called the Warren House, the building that housed the Sedberry was built in 1871, after the old building had burned down. That building had been built in 1820 and was called the John Cain house. It had several names and changed hands several times, eventually becoming an inn which, at one point, was called McMinnville Inn.

The establishment had its heyday, however, when Oceana Sedberry and her daughters, Erbye and Connie, took over in 1913. The Sedberrys came to McMinnville from Winchester where they had operated Winchester Hotel for a short time. After running the hotel for several very successful years, the Sedberrys purchased it in 1920.

Apparently the food was the source of much of the fame the Sedberry enjoyed during its prime years. According to a newspaper account in the Southern Standard following a dinner at the hotel, the menu consisted of, “celery, olives, oyster cocktail, wafers, broiled chicken on toast, peas en case, potatoes au gratin, French baked apples, rolls, cranberries in laced baskets, yellow yams en casserole, mint salad, melba parfoil, coffee, and cigars. The table was decorated with Killarney roses in silver baskets and pink tapers in crystal candlesticks.”

But, as it has been throughout history, all good things must come to an end, and the end for the Sedberry came in 1954 when the famed hotel and restaurant served its last meal and came under the auctioneers block. The Sedberry sold for $50,500, and from there, evolved into what is now the Cumberland Bank building.

Which still leaves the mystery of how that wall with the piece of the Sedberry sign still exists today. According to Dillon, the original building was torn down in the mid-’70s, and he wasn’t sure how some of the wall was left intact.

Thomas Duggin, who had been part owner of the building, thought maybe that the wall had once been a connecting wall between Crouch Drugs and the old building when the alley was closed in and became part of the Park Theater building. When the renovation of the Park began and the alley was opened back up, the old wall and the lettering was discovered and, thanks to some nostalgia minded contractors, framed in with new brick, and left for the public to marvel at for the first time in close to 50 years.

Duggin remembers the Sedberry well, but when asked if he had ever eaten there, said he had not.

“Miss Erbye wouldn’t let me in,” he said.

Why not?

“Well, we ran the Brown Hotel,” he said.

Leave a Comment