Skip to content

Media Musings: Press adds to nation of cynicism

As more and more investigative reporting hits our front pages and television news shows, it’s not difficult to understand why the stock market, our ultra-sensitive barometer of the next six months, waffles back and forth, back and forth, as sensitive as reeds are to the winds.

For nearly a decade, the financial press of the nation, like the stock brokers and “experts” yammering on CNBC, seemed to believe the stock market might really, really hit 30,000 (it would take 11,000 today and pop champagne bottles). There was no conspiracy here, either of silence or stupidity, on the part of the press. It was simple complacency.

It seemed to be a universal belief the “new economy” was unstoppable and billionaire doubters like Warren Buffett were, well, let’s be gentle, just nice old investors. He was yesterday’s economy, believing stocks should have dividends and companies should be profitable.

Novel thought, but don’t worry, said Jeff Bezos of Amazon dot com, some day, dear investor, some day there will be profits.

But, there is no doubt now, the financial watchdog press went to sleep, a deep sleep. The corruption of many top leaders by Enron and the destruction of as many rules and regulations as possible now show that only capitalism within a reasonable government oversight structure can protect the investors. Enron has left the working stiff nothing and paid its leaders millions, we now know, and perhaps it wasn’t possible to dig that story out, but the corruption and favor-granting may yet lead to the White House and especially Vice President Cheney if the reporters dig relentlessly.

While this corporate tragedy unfolds, other pieces are starting to vividly show corruption and outright manipulation in companies once above questioning. “Sixty Minutes” last Sunday showed how the Baby Bells are now four giant corporations unwilling to reveal how so many of its fees are gathered and spent. The billings they use leave everyone lost and there are many who believe that is a willful cover for suspected abuses. It was very revealing that no top person from any of the four giants, including Bell South, would talk. Some have settled out with some of the attorneys general for the practice of slamming, that is changing your account.

These kind of stories are like huge drops of acid on our social fibers. “Sixty Minutes” reported the Red Cross, imagine, paid its top executive in San Diego nearly $400,000 last year “for great work” and that chapter did not send the $56 million gathered for relief in that city to the people who needed it. Only because of the local press and then “Sixty Minutes” did the national people demand an audit and when it came, the San Diego board and the director “forgot” to talk about 10 pages of serious criticisms and issued a cover-up press release. The national leadership fired the director and the board a couple of weeks ago.

Another huge drop of acid on the fiber fell. Then there’s the Catholic Church stories of cover-up of pedophilia.

The church’s credibility has been so deeply damaged that one theologian believes it is as significant as the rebellion of Martin Luther. His commentary on National Public Radio pointed out Rome doesn’t understand how deep and serious the problem is. That the whole matter is an American problem, that it isn’t that big a problem but the church has to live in a secular society with an anti-Catholic Church press in the eyes of Rome.

Another huge drop of acid on the fiber fell.

The point of it all is investigative journalism is finding that corruption of institutions we believed were well regulated, honest, bastions of faith and service, was endemic. We are finding out every day our darkest suspicions are not the demons of our dreams, but the bitter truths of our worst human side.

Now, we watch and hope for the changes required to rebuild our confidences to become reality. But only to a certain degree. The age of cynicism seems now all too justified, after all.

(Ed Kimbrell is a professor in MTSU’s School of Journalism.)

Leave a Comment