Media Musings: News must keep pursuit of the truth
One of the constant charges leveled by conservatives against TV news is it’s liberal, too liberal, and the poor conservatives get little serious coverage.
Now comes the most recent research from Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting done for it by an independent firm. It says, in essence, the charge is a flat-out lie.
Consider the year 2001 numbers: 92 percent of all U.S. sources on the three major network news shows were white; 85 percent were male and when party affiliation could be identified, 75 percent were Republican.
Said directly, it is the American power structure on ABC, CBS and NBC nightly news casts.
The results show there was a desire to use official Washington sources. Also, the unions got almost no air time, as big business appeared 35 times more often than did union representatives.
How about women? They accounted for only 15 percent of all sources and were rarely featured as experts. When the nets searched for professional and political sources, only 9 percent of the total were women.
How about race? Those numbers were even worse, depending on your point of view. Only 7 percent were black and Latinos, Arab-Americans and Asian-Americans could not even muster 1 percent each.
Native Americans? One, yes – one out of 14,632 sources.
This column took a beating, too, in that it has claimed the big three network news shows would probably not remain part of our information world. FAIR found 25 percent of the the public is tuning in nightly to these reports, about 60 percent of the those who follow current events regularly. They are the voters, usually, and politically active as well.
One of the most important roles of the news business is the lifting up of many voices to be heard as the public makes up its own opinions about war, peace, poverty, religion, taxes and self-government. It is also charged with giving voice to the voiceless.
It’s going to sweat shops in the Far East and asking Kathy Lee Gifford, a millionaire, if she supported paying these workers virtually nothing as her line of clothes reaped in big bucks. (She has tried to make the conditions better and claimed she knew nothing of the shops until the media told her about it.)
It’s keeping the heat on Wall Street and Congress and the Global Communications and Enrons and Andersons to build new regulations to keep the financial world honest. There’s no profit there for the newspapers, but there sure is public service of the highest order. Merrill Lynch was slapped on the wrist for its lying brokers with a mere $100 million fine (that’s the salaries and bonuses of about 10 of the firm’s best salesmen a year).
There is waning confidence in the honesty of Wall Street and the networks, by being extensions of power, cannot easily rebuild the shattered trust in the financial markets. So, too, by being such an integrated part of the structures, the networks hurt their own credibility.
An example will suffice here: While the nets were going wild over Clinton’s sex scandal and closing world bureaus and cutting staffs to meet profit goals of their giant owners, 9/11 was building in Afghanistan. We are searching for why the FBI and the CIA and the NSA failed to, as the wonks say, connect the dots on the terrorist planning. We should also ask why these terrorist agencies were failures as coordinated bureaucracies long before 9/11. We spent $100 million – give or take a few million – to hammer the Clinton White House. Wonder how many super-computers that would have bought these agencies?
So, the situation is even more dangerous than just being an extension of power. It is hewing to the power line so closely, there’s no doubt the people – not the nets – will again be shocked and surprised and angered that the contrarian view – the ruthless pursuit of the truth – will not be heard when it is so desperately needed. Wall Street needs to set its house in order. So, too, do these shows.
Ed Kimbrell is a professor in MTSU’s School of Journalism.
