Teen-agers exact justice in the courtroom
“If anything, they’re more harsh,” Dishman said. “They know the rules and are familiar with the excuses the defendants use. They don’t work as well on them as they do on Judge Ross and me. We’re detached.”
Teen Court is almost exactly as its name suggests. Teen-agers from the high school and middle school assume the role of jurists, judges and attorneys to decide cases of some of their peers who have been accused of minor crimes such as shoplifting, truancy or violating their school behavior contracts. All teen-age defendants heard by the Teen Court are there by choice. Their alternative is to have their cases heard by Judge Ross.
“It’s a lot of fun,” said jury member and high school student Sara Foster. “It lets you see what you’re in for if you do break the law.”
At the end of each case, members of Teen Court decide on sentences for their accused peers. They can asses court costs, monetary restitution and order community service. They have even ordered one parent to attend school with her child.
“It’s just like regular court,” said Judge Ross.
All members of the Teen Court are sworn in and their rulings are legally binding. Of course, all rulings and proceedings are signed off on by Judge Ross and all defendants have the right to appeal their sentences if they choose.
The Teen Court concept was created close to 20 years ago by then-Gov. Lamar Alexander and has been practiced here in Warren County off and on since the mid 1980s.
Dishman said he believes Teen Court to be a positive experience for all involved. Teen Court members, he explained, have their eyes opened to the intricate workings of the legal system, which, for some, will lead to careers in law. For others, it serves to show them what could be in store for them should they ever break the law.
With the teen defendants, Dishman said, Teen Court can be a very effective tool. “Most of them are ashamed to stand in front of their peers. They know they can often con adults, but the people their own age that they go to school with know the truth.”
