Tennessee’s economy grew in 2005, employment rate modest
Auto manufacturing made some of the biggest news in 2005, for better and for worse.
Nissan Motor Co. will move its North American headquarters from Southern California to Middle Tennessee and build its first hybrid vehicle at the company’s Smyrna plant. But shortly after Nissan’s announcement, General Motors said it would close one of two production lines at its Saturn plant in Spring Hill.
Economists expect Nissan’s plans to help bolster long-term employment and growth in Tennessee despite GM’s announcement.
“We can certainly say the automotive industry will remain very strong in Tennessee,” said Bill Fox, an economics professor at the University of Tennessee. “It will be perceived better. It may or may not bring other automotive companies. But we still could get a lot of positive things that are spinoffs from the automotive industry. Attracting major headquarters even from outside the automotive industry is a positive.”
Automotive manufacturing was among a handful of industries in Tennessee that saw an increase in jobs in November compared to a year ago. Healthcare and educational services, trade, transportation and utilities, construction as well as leisure and hospitality industries also saw gains.
Apparel and textile manufacturing jobs suffered some of the biggest losses.
Economists say employment growth increased modestly for the year and hasn’t kept pace with the increase in sales and other tax revenues.
Tennessee’s unemployment rate for November was 5.8 percent compared to the national figure of 5 percent.
“Employers seem to be prospering, businesses seem to be doing well, but they’re not hiring as many additional folks as what we’d would like to see,” said David Penn, director of the Business and Economic Research Center at Middle Tennessee State University.
November’s year-over-year employment growth was 0.6 percent in Tennessee while sales tax revenues increased nearly 7 percent for August through November over the same period last year.
Franchise and excise tax revenue was up about 29 percent over the same four month-period last year.
“Hiring has not been quite as high as what we’d expect in November,” said Linda Davis, a labor market analyst with the Tennessee Department of Labor and Workforce Development. “Job growth has been consistent. It’s continuing to grow. It’s just not growing in huge numbers. Businesses don’t always fill jobs immediately when their sales go up.”
In November Nissan announced it was moving its Los Angeles area-based North American headquarters and nearly 1,300 jobs to the Nashville area to take advantage of the lower cost of doing business in the Southeast.
Nissan also said this year it had picked its Smyrna assembly plant for production of its first more fuel-efficient hybrid vehicle.
The company has a manufacturing headquarters in Smyrna and an engine plant in Decherd and is one of the largest employers in Tennessee with close to 8,000 workers.
Industry analysts say Nissan’s relocation could threaten Southern California’s dominance as a hub for Japanese automakers and strengthen the Southeast’s standing as a major vehicle manufacturing center.
Tennessee’s automotive industry, however, took a blow last month when GM announced it would have to cut more than a quarter of its North American manufacturing jobs, including some at its Spring Hill Saturn plant.
“The net effect of that is very difficult to know since we don’t know the magnitude of the Saturn cuts,” said Fox. “How many jobs that plays out to be in the end, we don’t know.”
One of the biggest automotive supplier expansions this year came from DENSO Manufacturing Tennessee, which recently announced a $185 million expansion of its Maryville assembly operations that is expected to add about 500 jobs by 2010.
State economic development officials say since Nissan’s decision to relocate the company’s headquarters to Tennessee, the state has caught the eyes of about a dozen other companies.
The state revamped its headquarters tax incentive rules earlier this year to make it easier to offer incentives to companies relocating their headquarters to Tennessee.
The headquarters tax incentive was created in the late 1990s — aimed at FedEx Corp. — and has since been given to International Paper and Medtronics in Memphis, and to Caterpillar Financial in Nashville.
International Paper announced in August it was moving its global headquarters to Memphis from Stamford, Conn.
In 2005, industry trade magazine Expansion Management ranked Nashville No. 1 for businesses seeking to expand or move. The city has recently landed corporate headquarters relocations by pharmaceutical benefits manager CareMark and building products company Louisiana-Pacific.
Tennessee’s economy in 2005 at a glance
MODEST EMPLOYMENT GROWTH — Tennessee businesses prospered in 2005, but that growth didn’t translate into the number of jobs economists say they would like to have seen.
TAX REVENUES UP — Economists say employment growth in Tennessee increased modestly for the year but hasn’t kept pace with the increase in sales and other tax revenues. November’s year-over-year employment growth was 0.6 percent in Tennessee while sales tax revenues increased nearly 7 percent for August through November over the same period last year.
JOB GAINS — Automotive manufacturing was among a handful of industries in Tennessee which saw an increase in jobs in November compared to a year ago. Health care and educational services, trade, transportation and utilities, construction as well as leisure and hospitality industries also saw gains.
JOB LOSSES — Apparel and textiles manufacturing jobs suffered some of the biggest losses.
