Armchair Quarterback: Giving the MVP nod to Alexander
Unlike the two years previous, Peyton Manning is not a shoe-in for the NFL’s Most Valuable Player Award, instead, he’s almost an underdog this year as seven players have shots at winning the honor this year.
Manning, who shared MVP honors with McNair two years ago and won it going away last year, probably isn’t even the top quarterback this year despite his 104.3 quarterback rating, 3,626 passing yards and 28 touchdowns. Actually, for Manning, it’s an off-year when you consider he had 49 touchdowns last season.
Instead, the top quarterback this year is Carson Palmer of the finally successful Cincinnati Bengals. The guy has been shredding defenses, throwing for 3,576 yards and two more TDs than Manning. His passer rating is just behind Manning at 102.6
While Palmer and Manning lead the quarterback class, along with even a dark horse candidate, Jake (The Snake) Plummer, who hasn’t got big numbers this year with the Broncos but has gained a reputation as a great game manager, the smart money is on a running back getting MVP honors this year.
Sure, a person could make the case of Panther receiver Steve Smith, who has 11 TD grabs and leads all receivers with 1,414 yards receiving. However, a receiver has never won MVP honors, partly because of their limited touches in a game. I’d also have to give honorable mention to Chad Johnson of the Bengals, who has eight TD grabs and 1,260 yards receiving, plus, he does it with a flare with his notorious end zone catches.
However, when the smoke clears this season, I expect the MVP to go to Alabama alum Shaun Alexander, who could be on a record-setting pace with the Seahawks this year. Denied by one single yard the rushing title last year, Alexander leads the way this season (well, as of Friday afternoon seeing there are Saturday games) with 1,665 yards. He also has in his sights the Priest Holmes single-season rushing touchdown mark of 27 as he has 24 right now. It’s a mark attainable provided he plays the final week of the season.
I think we all saw how he can take over a game as he put up 174 yards rushing on the Titans this past week, including a long TD run. He is averaging 5.1 yards per carry and 119 yards per game, his average yards per carry equaled only by Kansas City’s Larry Johnson, who, despite sharing playing time earlier in the year with Priest Holmes, is just a couple hundred yards behind Alexander. Had Johnson been the single back for the Chief all along, I believe he may have been this year’s MVP, considering what he has done with his seven solo performances following Holmes’ season ending concussion.
The only two backs I see rivaling Alexander on MVP ballots this year are Ladanian Tomlinson and Tiki Barber. Tomlinson was a more convincing pick before his numbers started to diminish a couple weeks ago. Meanwhile Barber’s stock continues to rise, as, like Tomlinson, he is a threat both out of the backfield and through the air. Barber has accounted for over 40 percent of the Giants’ total offense this year and he is getting five yards per carry, trailing Alexander by less than 100 yards rushing.
But, in the end I believe it will be Alexander who gets the nod for MVP given his near record-breaking performances and his consistent yards per game.
