Skip to content

Committee looks for pattern of fraud in Senate race

MEMPHIS, Tenn. Copyright 2005 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. ? A couple of votes, by themselves, don’t usually stir much interest in state Senate elections. But when they were supposedly cast by dead people, they get noticed.

Now, a Senate committee must decide how much weight to give two such votes amid a widening investigation into Democrat Ophelia Ford’s slim election victory over Republican Terry Roland in Memphis.

“I don’t know that two fraudulent votes constitutes a widespread pattern (of election fraud). I don’t want to overreact,” said Sen. Micheal Williams, chairman of the Senate committee.

It’s unclear yet how many questionable votes were counted in the September special election that gave Ford the senate seat vacated by her brother, John Ford, after he was indicted on federal bribery charges in the Tennessee.

Ophelia Ford was certified as a 13-vote victor in Senate District 29. Election officials now say, however, that they’ve found six votes that should not have been counted and at least three others that look a little shaky.

The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation, meanwhile, is looking into the votes registered to the deceased.

Roland wants a new election, and Williams’ committee was scheduled Wednesday to begin reviewing the latest report on the District 29 voting by the state’s election coordinator.

Coordinator Brook Thompson has rejected Roland’s contention that 68 improper votes were counted in the election, including ones cast by nonresidents of the district.

The committee is expected to report to the full Senate next month. It can recommend seating Ford, throwing out the election results or make no suggestions at all.

The Senate has the final say on whether a new election should be held, no matter how many troublesome ballots turn up.

In general, though, state law says new voting is justified if enough such problems are uncovered to undermine public confidence in an election. The number of improper votes does not have to exceed the winner’s margin of victory.

Williams, R-Maynardville, said critics of Ford’s victory may have to find a pattern of improper voting to get the election overturned.

“I don’t want to disenfranchise the voters of Shelby County,” he said, “because those people who went and voted, their votes should count, whether they voted for Roland or Miss Ford … The people who voted fraudulently, who did they vote for?”

Numerous phone messages left for Ford went unreturned.

In a legal response to the investigating Senate committee, Maclin P. Davis, an attorney for Roland, wrote that reports from election officials confirm that “numerous illegal votes were counted in the election of Sept. 15, 2005, and that there were widespread violations of election laws in that election.”

“Since it has been established that there were more than 13 illegal votes counted, the election should be declared void,” Davis wrote.

Roland began complaining election night that the voting was poorly monitored. The discovery of votes attributed to dead people came, however, from The Commercial Appeal newspaper following its review of voter rolls.

The ballots were both cast in the same Democratic precinct where Ford drew 32 of a total of 34 votes counted.

Using a dead person’s name to vote can bring a prison sentence of up to two years. And while no criminal charges have been filed, the newspaper’s reporting has stirred up both election camps.

Former U.S. Rep. Harold Ford Sr., also one of Ophelia Ford’s brothers, has accused Republicans of trying to create the appearance of election wrongdoing to hurt his son, Rep. Harold Ford Jr., D-Tenn., a candidate for the U.S. Senate.

Leave a Comment