Deputy governor key figure in Highway Patrol hiring
“That’s the person that we talked to in reference to what things we were doing, what moves we was making within the department,” Lynn Pitts said of Cooley during an interview with The Tennessean before scandal cost Pitts his job as head of the patrol.
Typically, state government promotions aside from political appointees go through an approval process that includes the department involved and the Personnel Department.
At THP, however, promotions were also run by Cooley, Pitts said. Even at the civil-service level, where job decisions are supposed to be free of politics, Cooley was consulted, The Tennessean reported.
Cooley did not return phone messages left by The Tennessean on Thursday and Friday. A Bredesen spokeswoman did not return phone messages from The Associated Press on Sunday.
A Tennessean investigation has shown that two-thirds of THP officers proposed for promotions under Bredesen had made campaign donations or had relatives or patrons who did. Of those, half were recommended over troopers with better scores on impartial exams.
Revelations about those promotions contributed to the forced departures this month of Pitts and his superiors, Safety Commissioner Fred Phillips and Deputy Commissioner Tom Moore.
Bredesen has said the department is plagued by cronyism.
In general, Pitts said, Phillips would talk to Cooley about THP promotions. But on at least one occasion, Pitts went directly to Cooley.
In a May 12, 2004, memo, Pitts wrote Cooley, “respectfully requesting” several personnel moves. The memo asks permission to award the rank of captain to Lt. Ronnie Shirley, who two months before had gotten a Rutherford County judge to dismiss a speeding ticket issued to Cooley by another trooper.
But Cooley did not promote Lt. Shirley. In a previous interview, the deputy governor said he opposed the promotion. At the time he did so, he said, he had no knowledge that Shirley had gone to a Rutherford County judge and had Cooley’s speeding ticket dismissed.
Besides Shirley’s promotion, the memo also asks permission to promote a trooper and a sergeant.
The sergeant that Pitts recommended for promotion to lieutenant was James W. Hutcherson Jr. of Dickson. Hutcherson was in fact tapped for promotion to lieutenant this past August. But the promotion was put on hold, along with all THP promotions, after The Tennessean reported the link between political connections and promotions.
Hutcherson and his relatives had given $420 to Bredesen’s 2002 campaign. On his application for promotion, he listed as a reference former THP officer Mike Dover, whose family has given at least $300 to Bredesen.
Although he did not respond to requests for comment for this story, Cooley acknowledged in the previous interview that political affiliation plays a role in some promotions, particularly executive service jobs.
“It may on occasion be put in the mix. It may not. I don’t think it’s a variable driving promotions,” Cooley said.
He added, “All things equal, it’s not unheard of.”
The personnel discussions he had regarding the THP were no different than those he had with other agencies from time to time, he said.
Cooley was active in forwarding recommendations for hiring and promoting troopers, according to THP records. A department spreadsheet lists Cooley on four recommendations for promotion and five for hires in the past two years.
One of the people the deputy governor is on record as recommending for hire, J. Eric Wise, had his driver’s license suspended. He was hired anyway. He showed up on the list of 58 THP personnel who were flagged in TBI background checks earlier this month.
Cooley is also a named defendant in a federal lawsuit filed by a former THP lieutenant in Knoxville. In it, Bryan Farmer, who says he was demoted and eventually fired for his Republican leanings, claims Cooley “exercised de facto control” over personnel decisions that retaliated against Farmer and other GOP supporters.
