Skip to content

Bottle bill opponents dispute Tennessee survey on bottle litter

KNOXVILLE, Tenn. Copyright 2005 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. ? A recent informal survey conducted by bottle bill proponents suggests that more than half of Tennessee’s roadside trash consists of beverage containers.

About 150 volunteers for the Tennessee Bottle Bill Project for Scenic Tennessee Inc. collected trash along 20.4 miles of road in 11 counties, separating the beverage containers from the rest of the litter.

Of the 4,602 total gallons of refuse picked up, 2,580.5 gallons, or 56 percent, were bottles and cans, project coordinator Marge Davis said. About three-fourths of the roads were rural, she said.

“Granted, this was not a highly scientific survey,” Davis said. “But considering that county after county reported similar results ? generally in the 50 percent to 60 percent range ? we think this survey paints a very fair picture of the composition of litter in Tennessee.”

Most of the discarded containers could be eliminated if the Legislature enacts a proposed law to require a 5-cent deposit on cans and bottles, Davis said.

A bottle deposit bill, sponsored by Rep. Russell Johnson, R-Loudon, and Sen. Randy McNally, R-Oak Ridge, was defeated after beverage industry lobbying last year, but Johnson vows to try again in the upcoming session.

Critics question Davis’ premise and the results of the litter survey.

Tom Salter, executive director of Keep Knoxville Beautiful, said the survey was designed to “sensationalize” the amount of litter along state roads.

If the survey had counted litter piece by piece instead of by volume it might have more closely resembled national and local studies that put the percentage of litter coming from beverage containers at 8 percent to 28 percent, he said.

“We do not believe a bottle bill will make a significant difference in the amount of roadside litter, but people may be led to believe that based on deliberately manipulated data,” Salter said.

Davis countered that counting litter piece by piece skews the results. “A plastic cup with a top and a straw gets separated and is three pieces,” she said. “Bottles and cans also last a lot longer as an eyesore, for years and years.”

Taxes on beer and soft drinks collected about $4.1 million last year for state litter programs. A bottle bill would more than double that to about $10 million.

The Tennessee Grocers and Convenience Association and the Tennessee Oil Marketers Association issued a joint press release last week calling the bill “a new consumer tax” that would just lead to a new bureaucracy.

‘

Bottle bill supporters: http://www.tnbottlebill.org

Bottle bill opponents: http://www.tnbottlebill.com

‘

Information from: The Knoxville News Sentinel, http://www.knoxnews.com

Leave a Comment