Cash, Underwood among top holiday music picks
Carrie Underwood, latest winner of the “American Idol” TV show, has the No. 1 album on Billboard’s country chart, while the late icon Johnny Cash holds the No. 3 and 13 spots.
Cash’s top entry is a greatest hits package, “The Legend of Johnny Cash,” and the other a movie soundtrack to the hit biopic “Walk the Line.”
“We sell a lot of Cash all through the year, but I think it’s increased since the movie,” said Kelly Keene, manager of Earnest Tubb Record Shop, an old brick building set among rows of bars and honky tonks downtown. “People come in and say, ‘I don’t really like country music, but I like Johnny Cash.'”
But Underwood and Cash won’t be enough to reverse a slump in country music sales in 2005. With business off about 10 percent this year, the industry is hoping for the best ? and expecting the worst.
“I’d like to end on a good note, but the reality is that this will probably end up as one of the worst Christmas seasons ever,” said Ben Kline, senior vice president of sales and marketing for Universal Music Group Nashville. “We had some major, major releases in 2004 and those records aren’t there this year. The guys in the middle are probably doing OK, but you need those big, big records to drive the bus.”
Sales from mid-November through New Year’s Eve are critical in the industry, accounting for 30 percent or more of the year’s total.
Record labels often load the final quarter with their biggest releases. This year, for example, records by Underwood, Cash, Kenny Chesney, Garth Brooks, Big & Rich, Martina McBride and Reba McEntire all came out around the holidays.
“It’s where you really make the year for the most part,” said Joe Galante, chairman of RCA Label Group/Nashville. “In that six-week period you can do what you normally do in six months.”
Even so, when 2005 ends, Kline and others expect sales to remain down by about 10 percent. On top of the soft release schedule, the country music industry was hurt by the Gulf Coast hurricanes and soaring gas prices.
“It’s a lot harder to sell CDs when gas is $3 a gallon than when it’s $2 a gallon,” Sony Music Nashville President John Grady said.
Sony BMG Music Entertainment had other problems as well. Last month the music giant pulled some of its most popular CDs from stores after complaints that anti-piracy software on the discs made them vulnerable to computer viruses.
The “XCP” copy-protection program was included on at least 20 titles, including a Sony Nashville release by country rockers Van Zant.
Grady said the problem has been corrected and the CDs restocked, but there were about two weeks when shoppers couldn’t buy them in stores.
“It hurt to have a product pulled out of stores in the middle of the season,” he said. “When you lose a sale at retail, it’s twice as hard to get it back because a lot of music is bought on impulse, and people’s impulses will take them to another piece of music.”
Sales are down across most musical genres, with overall sales off about 7 percent through September, according to Nielsen SoundScan.
Underwood’s strong showing should help. Her first album, “Some Hearts,” has big crossover potential. It debuted last month at No. 1 on Billboard’s country chart and No. 2 on its overall albums chart.
Cash has always transcended musical lines. His current resurgence is driven by the movie, which stars Joaquin Phoenix as Cash and Reese Witherspoon as his wife, June Carter Cash.
“Movies are sort of strange drivers. They can be over in a weekend or can attain a whole different life,” Grady said. “In the case of this movie, it will be a very strong two- or three-month film right through the center of the holidays.”
