Skip to content

TBI’s role in 2000-01 investigation of troopers is questioned

NASHVILLE, Tenn. Copyright 2005 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. ? The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation has been tapped by Gov. Phil Bredesen to investigate the state Highway Patrol, but the TBI’s involvement in a 2000-2001 investigation of ticket-fixing by troopers failed to follow up on all of the allegations, The Tennessean newspaper reports.

Bredesen called for the TBI’s involvement last week, citing concern that the patrol’s own internal investigation on allegations that troopers colluded with employees at a Knoxville meatpacking plant to have traffic tickets cleared was inadequate.

But TBI chief Mark Gwyn said the internal report and his agency’s involvement was thorough and that his only response to Bredesen’s request would be to turn over an internal affairs report by the THP to a prosecutor in East Tennessee for review.

“I’m the last person that should be Monday-morning quarterbacking this Internal Affairs, what they did,” Gwyn said. “But since the governor has asked us to look into it, I think the appropriate thing now is to take that to the DA, let him review it, let us sit down with him and say, ‘Let’s get on the same sheet here.'”

But last week Bredesen said that internal THP report “really calls into question for me the effectiveness of the … Internal Affairs … that a file can exist with those kind of allegations in it that at the very least were not followed up on.”

Bredesen did not have time Wednesday to respond to questions about the TBI’s involvement in the report, his spokeswoman told the newspaper.

The Highway Patrol, Tennessee’s top traffic enforcement agency, has been under fire amid allegations of political favoritism and corruption. Current and former troopers have said political pressure, campaign donations and a culture of favors for the powerful have dominated the THP for decades.

On Tuesday, the THP’s top officer, Col. Lynn Pitts, resigned after he was accused of violating state law by placing a winning bid on a fishing boat that was confiscated by the Department of Safety, which oversees THP.

The internal THP report conducted in 2000-01 looked into the allegations surrounding workers at the now-closed Lay Packing Co. in Knox County. Trooper Jerry Watson pleaded guilty in 2001 to erasing a ticket for one employee of the company.

No one else was prosecuted or convicted in the case, even though the man whose ticket was erased, Brandon Bright, said the practice happened often at the plant.

“I had heard that if an employee at Lay’s got a ticket from a trooper, you could always get it taken care of,” Bright told TBI Agent Chad Smith, according to a written statement signed by both men. “I assumed this was true because I often see troopers at Lay’s after hours in the alleyway, where I heard they are given meat. This happens once or twice a month.”

Smith declined comment.

But both the THP report and the TBI questions failed to find other instances of ticket-fixing, according to a review of investigation records by The Tennessean.

The former president of the firm, Joe Lay, said Wednesday that he was never interviewed by TBI or THP and had no knowledge of ticket-fixing.

In an October 2001 interview conducted by Richard “Dickie” Pope, then-assistant director of Internal Affairs for THP, Watson referred to a “bartering” system between the Lay employees and the troopers, who received meat from the plant.

But Pope did not pursue questions on what the troopers offered in exchange for the meat and did not follow up on rumors that a THP lieutenant had pressured Watson into fixing the ticket.

Pope said he did not follow up because Watson admitted guilt and did not implicate anyone else in the scheme.

The Tennessean also reported that Watson received significant help in his quest to clear his record and return to active duty by Lt. Col. Larry Rucker, who was named acting TBI commander after Pitts’ resignation on Tuesday.

Rucker was Watson’s supervisor in the Fall Branch district for 12 years. Records show Rucker accompanied Watson to an interview with TBI Agent Smith, wrote a complimentary letter and sought a report from a judge that showed Watson’s case was near to being expunged.

Because Rucker was present during Watson’s interview with TBI, he would have known about Watson’s claim that other officers routinely took meat from Lay employees.

Rucker declined comment on Monday, saying only: “I didn’t help him get it off his record. Let me say this, it’s under TBI investigation, so I’m not going to comment.”

The newspaper’s efforts to further investigate the case have been impeded by the TBI’s exemption from Tennessee’s open records act, it reported.

‘

Information from: The Tennessean, http://www.tennessean.com

Leave a Comment