Skip to content

Roland files court challenge over slim loss to Ford

NASHVILLE — The Republican business owner who lost a special election in Memphis for state Senate by just 13 votes to Ophelia Ford filed a challenge Friday, saying illegal voters swayed the election.

Terry Roland said a review of ballots showed a number of problems, including voters who voted in the wrong districts or at the wrong precincts. Those ballots should not be counted under state law, he argued in a challenge filed in chancery court in Memphis and with the state Senate.

“It’s gotten bigger than Terry Roland and the Senate race,” he said. “It is about the election process. It is about keeping the confidence of the people and the integrity of the election process.”

Roland lost to Ford by a vote of 4,333 to 4,320. Ford’s brother, John Ford, represented the Memphis Senate district for 31 years before resigning in May following his indictment on federal bribery and extortion charges.

The Ford family has long been a power in Memphis politics. John Ford’s brother, Harold Ford Sr., was Tennessee’s first black member of Congress before he was succeeded by his son, Harold Ford Jr., in 1996. Ford Jr. is running for the U.S. Senate seat to be vacated by Bill Frist in 2006. Family members have also been elected to numerous city and county offices.

Democrats quickly criticized Roland for challenging the election in court.

“It’s been clear from day one that Terry Roland and the Tennessee Republican Party would bring in national party lawyers from Washington to try to tangle up this special election in bogus legal knots,” said Bob Tuke, party chairman. “This strategy is straight out of the national Republican Party playbook.”

Tuke said the state party will help fight the challenge, and said Ford “won it fair and square.”

Roland’s challenge could ultimately seek a number of remedies, said his lawyer, Richard Fields.

The court could decide to force another election or declare Roland the victor. He said the state Senate could decide not to accept the results.

Fields, who is a Democrat, said the challenge is not about party politics.

“It’s not a matter of a bunch of Republicans trying to overturn the election, we’re just tired of having elections with irregularities,” Fields said.

Roland’s complaint says they found several problems with the election, including:

— 29 voters who are not registered to vote in Senate District 29.

— 31 voters didn’t sign a signature list and didn’t show identification.

— 113 voters who may have moved out of the district.

— 157 voters who do not appear on registration records.

“The Roland team has obviously uncovered some very disturbing information on the validity of this election,” said Tennessee GOP chairman Bob Davis. “Add all this up, and it doesn’t spell good news for the Ford dynasty.”

Fields said they are still sorting through voting records and uncovering more inconsistencies.

Leave a Comment