Companies offer workers deals to stay healthy
Worthington Industries Inc. last year began requiring workers to take responsibility for their health — by taking medication to help control their blood pressure or their cholesterol, for example — if they want the company to continue paying their entire health insurance premium.
“I had a choice to be lazy or lean,” said Brown, 44, an information technology employee who lost 90 pounds and has reached his goal of 210 pounds.
The steel processing company is among a growing number of employers turning to worker incentives to help slow health insurance costs. Fairview Health Services in Minneapolis gives gift certificates of up to $100 at the company store for workers who participate in health programs. Minneapolis-based UnitedHealthcare will knock about $100 a year off health insurance premiums for filling out a 10-minute health assessment online that asks employees about their diet and blood pressure and then suggests ways they can improve their health.
The nation’s largest hospital operator, HCA Inc. of Nashville, Tenn., said it saved $2.76 for every $1 it invested in 2002 when a group of its workers received $116 apiece as part of a program to reduce obesity.
“More employers are pursuing strategies to promote consumer responsibility, and incentives are part of such strategies,” Bruce Kelley, a senior consultant with the benefits consulting firm Watson Wyatt, said in an e-mail interview.
Health insurance costs have been rising at double-digit percentage levels for several years. The increase slowed from 12 percent in 2004 to 10 percent this year, according to a study by Watson Wyatt of 555 employers with at least 1,000 employees.
Kelley said many companies realize that without incentives beyond the potential for better health, programs tend to draw fewer workers or those at low risk of problems. The companies say a majority of workers are signing up, with Fairview Health estimating that 80 percent of its 13,000 employees participate in Fairview Alive, which started in 2001.
“That’s a smart strategy,” Kelley said of Worthington Industries’ Healthy Choices plan. “It takes the edge off of the negative message. In essence, the company is giving them a choice.”
In the program’s first year, workers are screened for blood pressure, cholesterol, blood sugar and weight and asked questions such as whether they wear a seat belt.
Employees designated at moderate or high risk must agree to counseling in the second year and then show progress toward meeting goals in the third year.
The company pays the insurance premiums as long as employees work toward their goals, which could be as simple as trying to climb a few flights of stairs.
Employees who don’t participate must pay $25 a month for single coverage insurance and $50 a month for family coverage, still far below what other corporate health plans require. Usually, workers pay an average of $64 a month for themselves and $200 for a family plan, according to a Watson Wyatt survey of employers.
At Fairview Health Services, workers who complete a health risk assessment receive gift certificates of $25, which they use to buy tickets to the theater and sporting events or clothes bearing the company logo. Employees who work with nurse specialists to manage diseases such as diabetes, heart problems or chronic conditions including arthritis can receive gift certificates of $100.
The increase in health insurance premiums has slowed to 9 percent a year over the past three years compared with national averages of 12 percent to 14 percent, said Barb Eischen, director of health and benefits services at the company, which operates hospitals and other medical services.
Health care consultant Allan Baumgarten said relying on inducements to help save money sounds like a new spin on programs in which companies offered counseling, for example, to help people quit smoking or lose weight.
“There is always something new you can try,” he said. “Whether or not you get any results that you can take to the bank is a little harder to see.”
John P. McConnell, president and chief executive of Worthington Industries, figures it will take five years to determine if Healthy Choices is cutting costs.
The company, which had $3 billion in sales in its last fiscal year, pays $30 million a year for health insurance. Premiums were up 15 percent to 17 percent in each of the three years before the program started and showed no signs of letting up, said Harry Goussetis, director of human resources.
Most companies require workers to pay a portion of their insurance. Worthington Industries has long been considered progressive when it comes to its relationship with workers.
Besides their salaries, workers receive a 17 percent share of the company profits, and the company’s headquarters has a barbershop, pharmacy and health and wellness center with three full-time doctors.
———
On the Net:
Worthington Industries: http://www.worthingtonindustries.com/
Watson Wyatt: http://www.watsonwyatt.com/
Fairview Health Services: http://www.fairview.org/
