Skip to content

GOLDBERG ON FOOTBALL: Four coaches who weren’t ready

Dennis Green’s last trip to Giants Stadium as a head coach was with Minnesota for the NFC championship game in January 2001. His team fell behind early and lost 41-0 in a game where it barely seemed to be trying.

On Sunday, Green’s Cardinals waited until the second half to fall apart in their 42-19 loss to the Giants.

But Green wasn’t the only coach shockingly unready for the first week of the 2005 season. St. Louis’ Mike Martz, Minnesota’s Mike Tice and the Jets’ Herman Edwards fell into the same category.

That’s inexcusable in a league where teams begin studying their opening-day opponents as soon as the schedule comes out in early spring. These aren’t rookies — they entered the season a combined 212-156 and had been to the playoffs 16 times in a total of 23 seasons as NFL head coaches.

Green did some strange things last year, such as a curious midseason quarterback shuffle when he benched Josh McCown for Sean King and raw rookie John Navarre. Had he stayed with McCown, the Cardinals might have made a rare playoff appearance.

This year, he brought in Kurt Warner to be the savior, even though Warner hasn’t been close to his two-time MVP form since 2001. That led to optimistic (almost giddy) predictions from Arizona and a lot of “experts” bought it.

But after Week 1, those predictions seem very exaggerated. Tom Coughlin clearly outcoached Green — after winning the first half 13-7, the Cardinals were outscored 35-6 by the Giants and used all three of their second-half timeouts in the first 10 minutes of the third quarter.

That might have cost them seven points. Plaxico Burress might have been out of bounds on a touchdown catch that gave the Giants a 35-19 lead, but Green couldn’t challenge the call because he didn’t have the timeout needed.

“It’s very noisy,” Green said in defense of Warner, who called all three timeouts.

Noisy? On the road?

Funny, Green knew how to take advantage of noise when he coached in Minnesota, so he should know how to combat it on the road. In fact, the Metrodome was so loud during the Green era that the league office had to tell the team to shelve the artificial clamor it added to the din from the fans.

As for the others:

— The Jets simply weren’t prepared for the intensity of the Kansas City defense, which was trying to prove that its annual makeover was real. Chad Pennington, adjusting to a new offense, fumbled six times and was lost in the shotgun.

But the whole team stunk. The game started with the Chiefs running three times for 75 yards and a touchdown.

“Obviously it’s one game,” Edwards said. “You have to take a look at yourself and say, ‘Did you play up to your expectations and if not why? Why didn’t we perform?’ We have to look at it and learn from it and move on.”

Sure. But this is a team with Super Bowl hopes, a team one successful field goal away from the AFC championship game last season. That one was on Edwards, too — he played too conservatively when his team was in range twice for the winning field goal in Pittsburgh, and the now-departed Doug Brien missed both kicks.

— The Vikings, supposedly an offensive power and a potential NFC title contender, didn’t score an offensive touchdown in that noisy Metrodome against a Tampa Bay team that was 5-11 a year ago.

Yes, Tice had to shuffle his offensive line when center Matt Birk was lost for the season, and the Bucs held Minnesota’s running backs to 14 yards on 12 carries, then forced three interceptions and two fumbles from Daunte Culpepper.

But the shuffle was a little strange.

Tice, who used to be an offensive line coach, altered three positions, benching starting guard Adam Goldberg for rookie Marcus Johnson so Goldberg could back up at all three positions. Goldberg finished at center in place of Cory Withrow, who in six previous seasons started all of five games.

— The Rams were clearly overconfident against San Francisco, 2-14 last season. Martz should have known that’s a trap, because the 49ers were at home playing their first game for Mike Nolan, an emotional coach who clearly was going to have his team fired up.

St. Louis, often bad on special teams, was horrible Sunday, allowing a punt return for a touchdown and an onside kick recovery; averaging 14.3 yards net on punts; and having a return man step out of bounds at his 1 on the opening kickoff. The result: a 28-25 loss to an inferior team.

All four coaches could have taken a lesson from Cincinnati’s Marvin Lewis, who in his first two seasons with the hitherto hapless Bengals has started 1-4 before finishing 8-8.

Taking his team into Cleveland, with a passionate crowd and a new coach in Romeo Crennel, he declared the opener a must-win. Then he sat down starting running back Rudi Johnson for violating a team rule, enough motivation that Johnson rushed for 126 yards when he got on the field.

But Lewis refused to praise his team after it won 27-13. And after rookie linebacker Odell Thurman, who trash-talked Browns players during the game, suggested afterward that his seven tackles would get noticed around the league, he was called into the Lewis’ office and told to shut up.

Those are the kind of details the other coaches seem to have forgotten.

———

DIRTY DOZEN

The top six and bottom six teams based on current level of play:

1. New England (1-0). Nice win, but Belichick found plenty of mistakes to discuss.

2. Indianapolis (1-0). Improved defense makes Colts real threat.

3. Pittsburgh (1-0). It was only Tennessee, but …

4. Atlanta (1-0). Defense and Vick.

5. Philadelphia (0-1). Jeremiah Trotter should have kept his cool.

6. New Orleans (1-0). America’s Team.

27. Washington (1-0). So Dan the Fan’s lads beat the Bears. So what?

28. Green Bay (0-1). Brett Favre deserves better in his golden years.

29. Houston (0-1). Just 120 yards of offense in Buffalo

30. Chicago (0-1). Kyle Orton shouldn’t have to begin this way.

31. Cleveland (0-1). Will try hard, but …

32. Tennessee (0-1). Jeff Fisher and Steve McNair deserve better, but the salary cap kills.

Leave a Comment