Virginia appeals court hears lesbian custody dispute
Lawyers for Lisa Miller-Jenkins, meanwhile, argued she should have sole custody of the child she conceived through artificial insemination during her civil union, pointing out former partner Janet Miller-Jenkins is neither the biological nor the legal adopted mother of 3-year-old Isabella.
It was the latest twist in an emotional case that’s become a standoff between courts in Virginia, where the women once lived and where the child’s mother now resides, and Vermont, where they wed and also lived briefly.
“The basic question here is whether Virginia had any authority to get involved,” said Rebecca Glenberg of the Virginia chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union, representing Janet Miller-Jenkins. “Vermont clearly has jurisdiction in this case and Virginia does not.”
The dispute dates to 2000 when the two Virginia residents traveled to Vermont for a civil union. Lisa Jenkins-Miller eventually gave birth to Isabella and two years later, the family moved back to Vermont. The women lived there for about one year before separating.
Lisa Miller-Jenkins, who since embraced Christianity and renounced her homosexuality, returned to Virginia and denied her former partner visitation rights.
She filed for full custody in Vermont in 2003, but in June 2004 a judge gave temporary visitation to Janet Miller-Jenkins. The next month, Lisa Miller-Jenkins filed for full custody in Virginia.
Last fall, a Frederick County, Va., judge granted Lisa Miller-Jenkins full custody of the child, citing Virginia’s anti-gay marriage laws. A Vermont judge followed with a ruling that Virginia had “improperly exercised jurisdiction” in acting in the case after it already had been opened in that state.
Wednesday, lawyers haggled over the nuances of federal and state acts surrounding same-sex unions and parental custody, focusing on the federal Defense of Marriage Act and the Parental Kidnapping Protection Act.
Judge Jean Harrison Clements questioned whether the former made Vermont’s ruling null in Virginia.
“Doesn’t DOMA say no other state (has) to recognize a civil union or any rights arising from them?” he asked.
But Janet Miller-Jenkins’ attorney Joseph Price argued that wasn’t intended to give one court power to overrule another.
Price accused Lisa Miller-Jenkins of “forum shopping” — moving from one state’s courts to another’s in hopes of securing a specific ruling.
The federal kidnapping protection act is designed to prevent such actions, he argued.
“The law doesn’t allow any parent, gay or straight … to shop state to state for a custody ruling they like,” Price said. “The question here is frankly very simple — was there a proceeding underway.”
But Lisa Miller-Jenkins’ lawyer Rena Lindevaldsen countered that the Vermont judge sidestepped laws there, making a custodial decision without determining whether Janet Miller-Jenkins was a legal parent. Without established parentage, she argued, federal kidnapping laws may not apply.
“There’s nothing in Vermont law that gives her parental status,” she said. “He cheated the law.”
Wednesday’s arguments came one week after the Vermont Supreme Court heard arguments in the dispute.
If the two states cannot resolve the conflict, the case could be decided by the U.S. Supreme Court.
Lindevaldsen urged the court to “look to Vermont law to determine if Vermont exercised proper jurisdiction.”
But Judge Jere M.H. Willis Jr. questioned what a ruling against Vermont could mean.
“Where are we then?” he asked. “Sounds like you’re starting the Civil War.”
The judges didn’t immediately make a decision.
Lisa wasn’t at the hearing. Janet has moved back to Vermont, but attended Wednesday.
“I’ve got a good feeling about what happened in the court room today,” she said afterward.
