Skip to content

City officials listened to views of the people

It’s been said most people favor progress, just not in their backyard. That was certainly the case Monday night for McMinnville residents who pleaded with city officials to keep a shopping center out of their neighborhood.

As with any story, there were two sides to this one and McMinnville’s Regional Planning Commission heard both.

In one corner was a shopping center developer who wanted to bring upscale stores to what is now a vacant field on Old Shelbyville Road. A major grocery store was planned as the shopping center anchor, along with an array of smaller stores and a restaurant.

Attractive landscaping was promised, as well as big-name chains that aren’t currently in McMinnville. The shopping center was projected to create well over 100 jobs, albeit not high-paying manufacturing jobs.

The developer claimed the shopping center would be a regional draw. Out-of-county residents might even be lured to town to spend their sales tax dollars here. For a community eager for jobs and economic growth, these were all positives.

But not everything surrounding the proposed shopping center was peachy, as dozens of nearby residents told the Planning Commission on Monday night.

The development would destroy their otherwise quaint neighborhood that’s peaceful and sheltered from outside traffic. A new shopping center, and all the cars and people accompanying it, would create an unsafe environment where children couldn’t ride bikes in the street.

Just look what’s happened to North Chancery Street since Wal-Mart moved into the neighborhood. A once-quiet side street has been transformed into one of the most heavily traveled roads in the county. As a result, most of the homes on North Chancery Street are for sale.

The people who live near the proposed site on Old Shelbyville Road certainly don’t want that. Nor do they want to look out their window and see a Dumpster where there was once a grassy field.

Mayor Royce Davenport was accurate when he said, “There are two good, completely different views of this property.”

Handling the growth of a city is a delicate task. We want to create jobs and stimulate economic development, but we don’t need to allow established neighborhoods to be turned into commercial districts either. This becomes especially challenging for cities like McMinnville with little available land.

Whether you supported the proposed shopping center or opposed it, one thing is reassuring. Planning Commission members listened to the concerns of city residents Monday night and acted accordingly.

There were a few scattered people who stood up and spoke in favor of the development, but the vast majority opposed it and were unwavering in their opposition. Those people let their voices be heard and the Planning Commission ultimately supported their views.

When it comes to government, that’s all any of us can ask. We want our voice to be heard. We expect our voice to be heard. And when it is, we can be thankful.

Leave a Comment