Skip to content

Woman sues therapist over alleged love affair

NASHVILLE (AP) — A woman who sought to change her sexual orientation through faith-based counseling is suing her female therapist, contending she was manipulated into having a homosexual relationship with the therapist.

Beverly A. Grubb, 59, alleges that Phyllis Garrison, a licensed clinical social worker at TrueHope for the Best Alternative in Brentwood, led her into an intimate domestic living arrangement that ended three months ago.

Grubb had gone to TrueHope hoping to be reoriented to heterosexuality in 1997.

The lawsuit, which names both Garrison and TrueHope, was filed last month in Williamson County Circuit Court.

Grubb is seeking unspecified damages for breach of confidentiality, emotional distress, lost wages and humiliation.

“I went to TrueHope for the cure and, while they didn’t cure me, I believe you can be cured,” Grubb told The Tennessean on Wednesday. “I’m a devout Christian. This isn’t real easy for me.”

Grubb, who has two adult children and was once married, said she recently overcame her attraction to the same sex by going to church, studying the Bible and praying.

“I was able to help myself,” she said. “I think TrueHope hurt me tremendously.”

Garrison declined to comment.

TrueHope’s attorney, James D. Kay Jr., said his client believes Grubbs’ claims are “outrageous” and said the counseling center will defend itself.

Kay said TrueHope, a nonprofit organization funded by local churches and private donors, is a faith-based ministry that counsels people with sexual issues.

The lawsuit charges that Garrison abused her authority. Grubb claims that she and Garrison purchased a home together and discussed confidential information about other TrueHope clients.

“Shortly after I went to them, Phyllis Garrison became my friend and said she couldn’t be my friend and therapist both,” Grubb said. “We became friends, and I moved in with her. You never imagine you will be friends with your therapist. I went to her for professional help.”

Leave a Comment