Skip to content

Bredesen signs law to stiffen child abuse penalties

KNOXVILLE (AP) — “Haley’s Law,” a statutory declaration that the torture of a child deserves a life in prison, was officially signed by Gov. Phil Bredesen on Tuesday with tiny abuse survivor Haley Spicer sitting on his lap.

“Thanks to the support of everybody in this community and throughout East Tennessee, Haley is safe and happy and healing at home with her mother,” the governor said during a ceremony at a Childhelp USA child abuse center.

“And by signing this legislation into law, we take another important step in assuring that other children do not have to go through what she did,” he said.

The bill adds a new offense of aggravated child neglect and endangerment to the code and changes most child abuse charges to felonies.

Defendants convicted of “especially heinous, atrocious or cruel” actions, including “the affliction of torture,” to victims under 8 years old can be sentenced to 15 to 80 years in prison. If the victim is over 8 years old, the term can be eight to 30 years.

“Any law that we pass cannot stop it from happening,” said Sen. Tommy Kilby, D-Wartburg, the bill’s main sponsor. “But we know that if they are caught they are going to have to pay a stiff penalty.”

Authorities found now 4-year-old Haley at her father’s mobile home in Campbell County in June 2004. She had been burned with cigarettes, scalded with hot water in a bathtub and beaten.

She required surgery to open her eyes and faces more operations to rebuild her nose and repair an injured ear. But her mother, Rose Mary Spicer of LaFollette, said Haley is doing OK. “Everything is going well,” she said.

Two months ago, Haley’s father, Tommy Joe Owens, 32, was convicted on three counts of aggravated child abuse and one count of neglect. Owens, a methamphetamine addict who claimed he never hurt her, faces up to 60 years on each count at sentencing in October.

His live-in girlfriend, Charlotte Claiborne, 31, pleaded no contest to the same charges and awaits sentencing of up to 20 years in prison. Meanwhile, baby sitter Teresa Draughn, 36, pleaded no contest to a misdemeanor charge of failing to report child abuse.

Rose Mary Spicer, who regained custody of her daughter as soon as the abuse was confirmed, said the harsher penalties under the new law will help.

“It is a wonderful thing,” she said. “People should be punished for abusing children.”

The Department of Children’s Services disciplined three employees for mishandling Haley’s case and failing to protect her.

While tougher laws help, Bredesen said DCS is “absolutely the front line against this. We have been working very hard over the past couple of years … to try to tighten up DCS and make it more responsive to these complaints.”

Some 39,000 cases of child abuse or neglect are reported annually to the state, said Jim Bailey, executive director for Tennessee Childhelp USA. “And the experts say the actual number is probably two times to three times higher than that,” he said.

Leave a Comment