Skip to content

Appeals court approves collection of felon’s blood

KNOXVILLE (AP) — The Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals has upheld taking blood from felons to sample their DNA, saying a prisoner’s right to privacy is outweighed by the need to solve crimes.

The ruling Friday was the first to test Tennessee’s law requiring felons to submit blood for DNA testing and establishing the process by which those samples are collected, compiled and used.

“The state’s interest in solving past and future crimes and exonerating individuals who have been wrongly convicted of crimes is great,” Appeals Judge Norma McGee Ogle wrote for the court.

“Therefore, under the balancing test, we conclude that Tennessee’s interest in the collection of blood … outweighs a defendant’s privacy interest and the minor intrusion caused by the taking of the blood sample.”

Saying the law passes federal and state constitutional muster, Ogle said, “Given this holding, the issue of the appellant’s consent is irrelevant.”

The state has been collecting blood from felons for several years. These DNA markers — unique to each person — are then stored in a database managed by the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation.

Many states have similar databases and laws on the collection of blood, and some half-dozen federal appeals courts have ruled the drawing of blood from criminals is constitutional. But Tennessee’s law had not yet been tested.

The opinion came in the case of Bruce Warren Scarborough, whose alleged attacks on University of Tennessee female students went unsolved for five years.

A random run through the state’s DNA database of a sample taken in one of those 1997 rapes led investigators to Scarborough, who was imprisoned in an unrelated case.

Without the DNA match, the case against Scarborough in four of the five rapes of which he is accused may crumble.

In all but one of the rapes, the victims never saw their attacker. He was a stranger to all five women. The women all were asleep when the attacker slipped inside their homes. The attacker took pains to cover their eyes, even using duct tape in at least one case.

Knox County Criminal Court Judge Mary Beth Leibowitz agreed last year to let the defense appeal the constitutionality of the DNA law before Scarborough goes to trial.

“It’s a big victory,” Assistant District Attorney General Kevin Allen said of the ruling.

Assistant Public Defender John R. Halstead said that he and Public Defender Mark Stephens are considering whether to appeal to the state Supreme Court.

Leave a Comment