Skip to content

Caldwell dogs sentenced to die:Pit bull, boxer deemed menaces to community

Caldwell dogs sentenced to die:Pit bull, boxer deemed menaces to community
Failure to stop while she was ahead may have sealed the fate for a pair of dogs which City Judge Tim Reed decreed Monday must be killed because they are a menace to the community.

Judge Reed’s decision in the case of a pit bull and boxer belonging to Brian and Erin Caldwell of Cherry Lane came minutes after he had spared the dogs’ lives, saying so long as they were kept outside the city limits he would not order them put down. However, continued talking by Mrs. Caldwell toward the city magistrate prompted a change of heart and an order the dogs be put down.

Judge Reed’s new order was met with cries of outrage from the Caldwells, who have maintained they are the target of a vendetta by some neighbors and the city. The Caldwells have 10 days to appeal the decision before the dogs, still in the custody of the animal shelter, are killed.

Reed made his decision after hearing several people testify about the danger of the dogs. Kenny Knight, a neighbor, noted his 11-year-old daughter was knocked off her bike and mauled by the boxer, requiring medical attention. He has charged Mr. Caldwell in criminal court in a case which is pending.

In response, the Caldwells maintained the girl constantly teased their dogs, which were kept in the yard mostly be an invisible fence and shock collars. On the day in question, the Caldwells maintained the girl was playing a clarinet in the road to antagonize their dog.

“So you’re saying this little girl was playing a clarinet in the road, and then 15 minutes later, while she was riding her bike, this dog remembered it and decided to get revenge,” asked City Attorney Michael Galligan.

“Do you have a degree in dogs?” asked Mr. Caldwell of Galligan’s question.

Also taking the podium was city meter reader Aaron Wrisner who has charged Mr. Caldwell with assault for swinging at him. Wrisner said the pit bull attacked him by grabbing his pants leg while he was reading a meter there and that he had swung at the dog with a pole. It was at that point Wrisner said Mr. Caldwell came out and hit him in the arm with a stick. Mr. Caldwell denies striking Wrisner.

Along with another neighbor, who said one of the dogs killed her cat, and a mail carrier who witnessed the cat attack, McMinnville Police Investigator Barry Powers testified the dogs came after him while he was at the Caldwell residence

“They are both aggressive dogs,” Powers said.

In response to the people who said they were in fear in the Cherry Lane neighborhood, Mr. Caldwell maintained that while territorial, the dogs are not a threat.

“If I felt they posed a jeopardy to kids, I’d take them out back and shoot them myself,” Mr. Caldwell said, noting aside from one 15-minute escape, he believed his dogs had been kept on chains since the city ordered it last month.

However, Judge Reed said that was not good enough given the apparent threat the dogs present.

“A dog can kill a little child in no time at all,” Reed said. “I sure wouldn’t want my children to live in that neighborhood. If those were my dogs, I’d have them put down myself.”

Leave a Comment