Lawyers say Tennessee’s illegal tax law is ripe for abuse
Since the law took effect in January, Tennessee’s Department of Revenue has collected nearly $400,000 in taxes. Another $11 million in taxes have been levied, but not collected because debtors can’t afford it or are in jail.
“This law is tailor-made for governmental abuse,” Nashville criminal defense attorney Glenn Funk said.
Michael Garcia, 30, was mistakenly suspected by police for using his car to run interference for a drug dealer in Springfield. He wasn’t arrested or charged, but six days later he received a letter from the state demanding he pay $17,592 in taxes he owed for his role in drug trafficking.
He figured it was a mistake.
“The revenue guys showed up with the bulletproof vests and the guns and stuff, and that’s when I knew it was for real,” Garcia said.
The law makes drug traffickers go to any of the state revenue offices within 48 hours of coming into possession of illegal drugs. They pay a tax on the value of the illegal drugs and get a stamp to show they have paid.
Privacy laws keep Department of Revenue officials from reporting the people to police agencies, officials said.
The Department of Revenue has sent a notice of lien on Garcia’s property while he appeals.
People who think they have been assessed the tax unfairly have 30 days to appeal and the lawyer for the state tax department hears the appeals.
“That’s like the fox guarding the henhouse,” Garcia’s attorney, Erik Herbert said.
If denied, people may then file a lawsuit against the Department of Revenue in Chancery Court.
Garcia has been paying for an attorney to handle his case. Some critics say that many people who are assessed the tax cannot afford to hire private lawyers.
“The biggest beef the attorneys and citizens have with this is that you’re guilty until proven innocent,” Herbert said.
Tennessee’s drug tax is modeled after a similar law in North Carolina.
That state has collected more than $89 million in the 15 years since it was put on the books. The drug taxes are intended as a way to generate money that can be used to offset the cost of drug trafficking to law enforcement.
In both states, the bulk of the taxes being collected have been levied after the drugs were seized.
Allen St. Pierre, executive director of the National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws said that North Carolina’s law has withstood legal scrutiny. But he still expects challenges in Tennessee.
“The Tennessee Supreme Court will absolutely, positively, be litigating a case having to do with these drug taxes,” St. Pierre said.
The drug tax is an attempt to circumvent laws designed to protect people not yet convicted of crimes, Funk said.
“The burden is on the citizen to initiate the lawsuit and get their money back, and not everybody will be able to do that,” he said. “There has to be in America some responsibility for the government to prove the citizen did something wrong before it punishes the citizen.”
