Skip to content

In fourth place, NBC has no place to go but up. But will it?

NEW YORK (AP) — At its best, a TV network looks even greater than the sum of its programs.

Look at NBC from the 1980s into the ’90s, resonating with “The Cosby Show,” “Cheers,” “Seinfeld” and “Friends”; with “Hill Street Blues,” “St. Elsewhere,” “L.A. Law” and a still vibrant “ER.” NBC was scoring big with great stuff, and the aura of such programs was more than sufficient to outshine its less glowing fare.

This was a golden era set in motion by Grant Tinker, whose arrival in 1981 as NBC chairman signaled the rebirth of a broken network.

But now that era is a distant memory. Present-day NBC mocks that glorious past.

Dismal numbers help explain: For the season just ended, NBC fell 17 percent among 18-to-49-year-old viewers in an unprecedented plunge from first to fourth place.

But the problem is more than ratings.

In recent years, NBC has shown little evidence of vision or taste. It scores, when it scores, with stunts more than solid entertainment. It relies on repackaging old successes in the hope they pay off one more time, while clinging to aging hits for dear life.

Even the programs touted as innovative (like last fall’s cartoon sitcom “Father of the Pride”) are timid and derivative.

There’s lots of sizzle, but where are the steaks? Not on NBC in prime time under Jeff Zucker’s rule.

At age 40, he has outgrown his image as a whiz kid. But at 26, Zucker earned it by becoming executive producer of “Today.” Then, as if that weren’t enough to clinch the Boy Wonder title, at 27 he briefly served as executive producer of “Today” and “NBC Nightly News” simultaneously.

In December 2000, Zucker left “Today” the undisputed morning champ, to take over NBC’s entertainment division. A year ago he was crowned president of the NBC Universal Television Group, in charge of that conglomerate’s entertainment, news and cable channels. He is said to be in line for chairman of NBC Universal when Robert Wright retires.

Good for Zucker. But for NBC’s audience on any given night, the Zucker legacy after 4 1/2 years could be summed up in these not-so-great terms: “Fear Factor,” “The Apprentice,” artificially inflated sitcom episodes, and, of course, “Law & Order” all over the place.

Nothing if not a salesman, Zucker last summer was hyping NBC’s five new fall shows as “better than we’ve had in a long time.” Then four of them bombed with viewers and critics alike, while the fifth, “Joey,” won a reprieve for the coming season even with Zucker’s acknowledgment that this “Friends” spinoff had been a disappointment.

Unveiled May 16 by Zucker and his entertainment chief Kevin Reilly, NBC’s fall 2005 slate includes six new series, among them a Jerry Bruckheimer-produced action-intrigue hour (“E-Ring”), a second “Apprentice” with Martha Stewart, and “Inconceivable,” a medical drama set in a fertility clinic.

This lineup has wowed no one and left some media analysts scratching their heads. (Why, for instance, no overhaul on Thursday, where NBC has lost its “Must-See” grip after a two-decade reign?)

But perhaps the biggest surprise was a show conspicuously absent: “Law & Order: Trial By Jury,” the fourth (and only weeks-old) version of the franchise that ate NBC. Does its unexpected cancellation betray a larger weakness — or a crisis of faith — in the franchise that lately has kept NBC afloat?

The same afternoon Zucker presented the fall schedule to advertisers at Radio City Music Hall, Grant Tinker was four blocks away at the Waldorf-Astoria Hotel. He was getting a prestigious Peabody award for his career running NBC and, before that, building MTM Enterprises, the legendary home of such series as “The Mary Tyler Moore Show,” “The Bob Newhart Show” and “Hill Street Blues.”

Receiving his medallion during the annual Peabody luncheon, Tinker, famously modest, called himself “a guy of no distinct or specific skills (who) always needed a lot of help.”

“And I’ve always had a lot of help,” he added. “You know: really heavy lifters.”

That is his legacy: Recruiting the best creative people, and letting them do what they do best.

But while Tinker let other people make TV, Zucker has a history of making it himself. At “Today” he made TV by the carload — hour after hour, live and on the fly.

How that prepares someone to steward a well-rounded prime-time network schedule remains unclear. But Zucker has other responsibilities, too. Like “Today,” whose dwindling lead over its ABC rival, “Good Morning America,” has recently spurred hands-on crisis management from Zucker.

In April, “Today” executive producer Tom Touchet was sacked. Then, during the first week for his successor, Jim Bell, Zucker “jarred some on the `Today’ staff by reporting to the control room each day and helping produce the show as if he had never left,” according to The New York Times.

Which raises this question as the season ends: If Zucker had never left “Today,” how would NBC look in prime time now?

———

On the Net:

www.nbc.com

———

EDITOR’S NOTE — Frazier Moore can be reached at fmoore(at)ap.org

Leave a Comment