Loophole could exempt Naifeh, lobbyist wife from ethics law
The bill, which is headed for a Senate vote Monday after passing the House last week, includes a loophole that would exempt Naifeh and his wife, lobbyist Betty Anderson, from the disclosure requirement.
Wording added to the bill before it was finalized last week requires lawmakers “or a spouse residing with such person” to disclose income sources.
But Anderson owns a home outside Naifeh’s West Tennessee district. Records show she purchased the half-million-dollar home in Nashville’s Green Hills neighborhood in August.
Last year she also updated her driver’s license to show her Nashville address, records show. According to Naifeh, Anderson also changed her voting registration to Nashville from her Covington, Tenn., home, where Naifeh is still listed.
That means that Naifeh, if he chose to, would not have to disclose the source of income that Anderson might bring into the Naifeh/Anderson family.
The speaker, who voted for the ethics bill Thursday, said he wasn’t aware the language in the bill created such an exemption.
Legislative leaders from both parties said the exemption was unintended. After being told of the loophole Friday, they pledged to introduce a bill that would fix the wording.
“I didn’t know it was written up that way,” Naifeh said. “If we did make any mistakes, we will clean them up.”
Other provisions of the bill are being questioned as well. One says legislators must declare publicly if a bill before them has been lobbied by a brother, sister, a spouse or one of their children. However, there is no provision that says a lawmaker must recuse himself or herself from voting on the bill, which is a law in many states. Even if the lawmaker does not declare a conflict he or she might have with legislation, the bill contains no provision for punishing the lawmaker for his or her refusal to do so.
Another provision forbids lawmakers, other top state officials and local elected officials from accepting money for promoting legislation or securing contracts, but staff with the General Assembly and virtually every other state employee are eligible to do so as long as they disclose the fee and who paid it.
“This is far from as strong as it should be,” said David Amonette of Portland, a longtime municipal attorney who has experience drafting legislation. He fears that if there are too many loopholes, the legislature might not be able to fix its image.
“I have so many questions about it. It’s so disjointed,” Amonette said of the bill.
The legislation, though, does tighten disclosure laws. And good-government groups and watchdog organizations have mostly applauded it.
Stephen Zralek, an attorney with Nashville-based Bone McAllester Norton and an expert in campaign finance law, noted that the proposed law would mean not only lawmakers but public officials statewide would have to disclose more about their private business dealings. And the measure expands the state’s bribery statute, he said.
“It’s a step in the right direction,” Zralek said.
