Soldier’s wife complains about TV series based on Iraq war
Tucker calls it “disrespectful and distasteful” to air shows about an ongoing war. Her husband, Sgt. 1st Class Wayne Tucker, is in Iraq with a Kentucky National Guard transportation unit. A member of the unit died recently when a bomb exploded near his military vehicle.
“This series may have fictional characters but our loved ones are real and we don’t need to be reminded the dangers they face everyday from a series whose sole purpose is for entertainment and ratings,” Tucker wrote to other military families.
Tucker’s campaign has drawn a mixed response from military families. Some have written or promised letters of protest, while others play down the upcoming series.
“If you don’t like it, don’t watch it,” said Sarah Boothe, whose husband, Sgt. Michael Boothe, is in the same unit as Tucker’s husband, the 2113th Transportation Company.
FX spokesman John Solberg said the new prime-time show, called “Over There,” is scheduled to debut in July. The cable network has ordered 13 shows.
The series will focus on members of a U.S. Army unit on its first tour of duty in Iraq. It examines the physical and emotional challenges encountered by soldiers, as well as the war’s effects on families back home, according to an FX release publicizing the series.
“The show doesn’t really take any political stance on the war,” Solberg said in a phone interview this week. “It’s not about policy.”
Tucker expressed her concerns in a recent phone conversation with Chris Gerolmo, the show’s co-creator and executive producer. The show’s other creator is Steven Bochco, who also created and was executive producer of such shows as “L.A. Law” and “NYPD Blue.”
Tucker started her campaign recently after watching an FX commercial promoting “Over There.” It showed two U.S. soldiers relaxing against a wall when a mortar explodes.
“It stunned me, angered me and I was horrified,” said Tucker, of Elizabethtown.
Solberg said the pilot episode includes an intense battle scene. As for whether the series will depict U.S. soldiers being killed or wounded, he said, “It’s going to be a depiction of war.”
Barbara Hornback of Sonora, the mother of Pfc. Megan Hornback, who is in the 2113th, wrote in a letter for Gerolmo that she worried the show would prompt schoolmates of Megan’s sister and brother to ask them questions, raising their anxiety about their soldier-sister.
“I feel the war in Iraq is far from over and I don’t need a television show to know what is going on `Over There,'” she wrote. “I already know. I do wish you would consider the pain you are going to bring to many families.”
Robin Butts of Paducah, the wife of Sgt. Christopher Butts, also in the 2113th, said the show’s producers need to think about the feelings of families with loved ones in Iraq.
“At times I have my own thoughts running through my head,” she wrote. “I definitely do not need any help or any more `new’ thoughts thrown in my face.”
Not every military wife or mother shares Tucker’s outrage.
“I applaud her for what she’s doing, but I think she’s being a little judgmental because the show hasn’t even aired,” said Angela Dodge, whose husband, Sgt. Gregory Dodge, is in the 2113th.
Boothe, herself a member of a Kentucky Guard military police unit, said the show would probably be “no different than watching the news every night.”
“It wouldn’t bother me to watch it,” said Boothe, of Owenton. “I’m not going to say that I’m going to watch it. But I’m just saying if I turned it on, I’m not going to be oversensitive about it. And if I did, then I would just turn it off.”
Dodge said she would withhold her opinion until the show airs.
“If it’s that disrespectful and it’s that bad, I’m sure that it will die it’s own natural death,” she said. “But we do have the right to switch the channel. This is a free country.”
If done tastefully, she said, the show could raise awareness of the war.
“What my hope would be is that they would approach the series in a manner in which it would remind people exactly what our soldiers are doing over there, not something (with) sensationalism,” said Dodge, who lives in Jefferson County.
Terry Muir, whose son, Sgt. John R. Muir, is in the same Kentucky Guard unit, predicted the show would evoke a range of emotions from military families. “Some are going to be totally fascinated,” she said. “It could upset others, it could terrify others.”
Muir, of Mayfield, said viewers should remember that the show is a fictional depiction.
“I hope that anyone that watches this does not take this as the truth being unfolded before them,” she said. “Hollywood is Hollywood.”
