Small number of women hold seats on boards of Tennessee companies
“Though this information is not surprising, it is moderately depressing,” said Laura Smith, chairwoman of the Women on Boards committee for CABLE, one of Tennessee’s largest and most active businesswomen groups.
The CABLE study, which was conducted by the Vanderbilt University Women’s Social Policy and Research Center, looked at the 105 Tennessee companies that filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission during 2004.
Women hold only 60 of the 819 board seats in these public companies, and only six were held by nonwhite women. About half the Tennessee companies had no women on their boards.
The news was not as bleak for Fortune 500 companies in Tennessee, which have a higher percentage of women on corporate boards than any other state.
“On a relative basis, looking just at the Fortune 500, (Tennessee is) ahead of the game,” said Deborah Soon, vice president of Executive Leadership Initiatives for the New York City-based Catalyst, a business women’s organization which provided data for the CABLE study.
About 15.5 percent of board seats were held by women among Tennessee’s Fortune 500 companies in 2003. The national average was 13.6 percent, according to Catalyst data.
Fortune 500 companies tend to have more diverse boards because it makes good financial sense, Soon said.
“For corporations who had the most diversification in terms of gender in the top leadership tier, the executive team, those companies outperformed those who had the least diversification,” Soon said.
In Tennessee, Pinnacle Financial Partners Inc. in Nashville has the most women on its board — three.
Tennessee companies with two women on the board include AmSurg Corp., HCA Inc., Tractor Supply Co., Caremark Rx Inc., Dollar General Corp., CBRL Group Inc., FedEx Corp. and First Tennessee National Corp.
Of Tennessee companies’ 665 executive positions — usually considered a pipeline for board candidates — 71 positions were held by women. Nonwhite women held only three executive positions.
Several reasons account for women’s lag behind men when it comes to board presence. Women often lack an influential sponsor or role model, and they don’t get high-visibility assignments. Existing boards are also made up of mostly white men.
“It’s still sort of an old boys’ network,” said Billye Sanders, the first black woman partner at her Nashville law firm Waller Lansden Dortch & Davis.
“These boards are self-perpetuating. The people on the board decide who’s on the board. So they tend to invite people who are like them. Boards also tend to have CEOs of businesses. So you don’t have as many women in the pipeline because there aren’t many women who are CEOs of businesses.”
Linda Rebrovick, executive vice president of Bearing Point, a Washington-based consulting company with offices in Nashville, sits on two Tennessee boards, Pinnacle Financial Partners and Healthstream, Inc. She said she was chosen for those positions because of her technology expertise, business consulting experience and her contacts in the community.
“If women don’t have the expertise today to go to a public board, they should focus on being on a private board,” Rebrovick said. “They should gain the experience, knowledge and relationships that you get there and then try to get on a public board.
“Second make sure you’re constantly networking and voicing interest,” she added. “A lot of it is just telling the right people you want to serve on boards because that’s a big-time commitment.”
