Nashville police ax audio on planned monitoring cameras
Public pressure over the proposed surveillance network led police to scrap plans for the audio monitoring system that would have allowed officers to randomly eavesdrop on conversations in public places. The video network, without audio recording devices, remains on track.
“As we thought more about audio, and as we listened to public discussion about this entire subject, we didn’t want the benefit of overt surveillance cameras being overshadowed by the audio issue,” police spokesman Don Aaron said.
The city’s request for bids on the camera system generated questions and criticism from a variety of sources, including some Metro Nashville Council members and Internet discussion forums.
The police department still plans to place six cameras in the downtown area and a neighborhood to the east, both considered higher crime areas. More cameras could be installed if the system is considered successful.
Police Chief Ronal Serpas has said he hopes the cameras will catch criminal acts and deter some from committing crimes.
The department’s $1.6 million asset forfeiture fund, which comes from the seizure of property or money during an investigation, will pay for the system.
Memphis police installed a dozen cameras in the mid-1990s in the downtown business district, but the system was abandoned because of technical problems.
Similar projects across the country have been criticized as an invasion of privacy.
Hedy Weinberg, executive director of the ACLU of Tennessee, praised Serpas’ decision as a “first step.” The organization still opposes plans for random video monitoring.
“I think that one’s right to privacy is not a liberal or conservative, or a left or right value,” she said. “All of us assume there is an expectation of privacy, and we don’t believe that our private conversations or images should be captured by government cameras.”
Serpas has said he hopes to sidestep that complaint by not hiding Nashville’s cameras. The equipment will have visible police logos and flashing, rotating blue lights.
“We’re not playing hide-and-seek with criminals,” he said. “This is going to say, ‘We’re right here and we’re watching this block.'”
———
Information from: The Tennessean, http://www.tennessean.com
