Skip to content

Annexed residents likely to get trial against city

Annexed residents likely to get trial against city

DORRIS
Residents who filed a lawsuit against the city of McMinnville to fight annexation plans may get their day in court after all.

Overturning a previous decision, the Tennessee Court of Appeals has ruled in favor of the residents and said the case should go to trial.

“They’ll have their day in court,” said Richard Dorris, who is one of the attorneys representing affected residents. “We’ll start back at the trial level.”

The annexation cases have been tied up for years and date back to 2001, when city officials attempted to annex hundreds of acres of land southwest of town.

The Warren County Commission was supposed to file a lawsuit on behalf of the residents, but didn’t submit paperwork on time. Residents, however, filed separately and submitted their lawsuit before the deadline.

According to court documents, Warren County Circuit Court dismissed the citizens’ cases in a 2003 ruling, saying citizens chose their path of law when they asked county government to file a lawsuit on their behalf. The appeals court said even if citizens had asked the county to act on their behalf, that did not preclude them from acting themselves.

The appeals court also clarified discrepancies between two state laws establishing the time allowed for different parties to contest annexation.

“We find that the two statutory schemes for annexation are not mutually exclusive. The landowners have a right to contest annexation independent from that of the county, and the period of limitations for the landowners to file actions to contest annexation was 90 days,” wrote Judge Frank G. Clement Jr. in delivering the opinion of the court. Citizens filed in 88 days.

In response to the ruling, city attorney Mike Galligan said there has been no decision made as to the city’s next steps since the ruling, which vacated the previous court decision and remanded it to the trial level, was just handed down Monday.

“The options are to appeal it to the Supreme Court. They don’t have to accept it, but they might. The other options would be to proceed in accordance with the ruling of the court and of course, other options might be to consider the whole situation, and that will be up to the board,” he said.

Galligan noted once deliberations begin at the McMinnville Board of Mayor and Aldermen level as to what steps to take in response to the court’s ruling, those decisions would be open to the public in accordance with the state’s Sunshine Law.

Leave a Comment