Skip to content

Armchair Quarterback: It’s no cliché — Defense wins championships

Robert Rudelitch

Robert Rudelitch

So much for a showdown between Manning and Vick in the Super Bowl, seeing one was sent home packing this past week.

Before the 20-3 domination by the Pats last Sunday, most experts were saying there was no way anyone could stop Peyton Manning and the Colt offense. Hey, to see them crush the Broncos last week, I can see why people would think that. I personally refused to weigh in seeing I’m still smarting from that whole Sooner debacle. Winning the Pigskin Panel this year did little to offset my horrible selection of that game.

From what I was hearing last week on ESPN and other sports shows, the general bailout claim was that to win the Pats would have to score 35 points. Of course, I think these estimations were made out of hopefulness, not out of looking at the recent history of the game. The saying which has been proven true year after year — “offense fills the seats and defense wins championships” — is something the Colts will be hearing all week.

It isn’t rocket science. Defense has been delivering in the playoffs since I was a little kid, and I turn 40 next month. Just look at the past five years. We had the defensive minded Pats last year and three years ago, we had the defensive powerhouse Bucs sandwiched in between those wins, four years ago we had the Ravens and five years ago, yes, we had the Rams. While they may be remembered for being the “Greatest Show on Turf” back during their heyday, the Rams also led the league in defense the year they beat the Titans in the Super Bowl, surrendering just an average 12 points per game.

Manning is not alone in his failure during the cold winter months against tough defenses. The man whose record he broke, Dan Marino, met a similar Waterloo back in the 1984-85 season, the same year he threw 48 touchdown passes to guys like Mark Clayton and Mark Duper. While making it all the way to the Super Bowl, his only Super Bowl by the way, Marino was shut down by Ronnie Lott and the San Francisco 49ers.

While Joe Montana may be credited for leading his team over the Dolphins that year, it was defense which won the day. Sure, the Niners scored 38, but most of those points were set up on big plays made by the defense. Marino was limited to 16, most of which came at trash time at the end. It just goes to show that super seasons do not always mean Super Bowl rings.

Some will claim cold weather has a big role to play during crunch time in the playoffs. At first glance I might agree, given the successes years ago of the Bills in Buffalo and the Broncos in the thin air of Mile High and even the recent domination of the Pats. However, there are two problems with this theory. First, two of the five recent champs weren’t cold weather teams. The Bucs play in Florida and the Rams play inside. Second, and most importantly, to play at home in January you’ve got to win a lot of games in the regular season to get home field advantage. And, aside from the Rams, none of the recent five champs had a dominant offense, so they obviously made their hay on defense.

What’s all this mean for this week’s games? Well, I haven’t the slightest between the Steelers and the Pats since they are both defensive teams. The Philly and Atlanta game would seem to be in the Eagles’ favor at first glance, but then again, the Falcons are getting to be known not just for Vick, but also for their defense. Any way it goes today and in the upcoming Super Bowl, the defensive theory of football will be proven right again since all four teams remaining, even Atlanta to a degree, are known for their defense.

Leave a Comment