Skip to content

Upon Further Review: Manning’s legacy — Hero, or choker?

Most people have one favorite team they grew up pulling for. I had two.

In the ’60s, it was the Colts, and in the ’70s, it became the Steelers with their steel curtain defense.

Over the past several years, however, my attention has turned back toward the Colts, due in large part to Peyton Manning.

Manning and his success at Tennessee brought back a spark of life to football at Neyland Stadium. He rewrote several record books and became a household name even beyond the Volunteer state.

But just how good is he, and has his legacy of losing the big one carried over into his professional career?

After Sunday’s performance against New England, Manning is now 0-7 at Foxboro.

The league’s MVP completed 27-of-42 passes for 238 yards with no touchdowns. The Colts’ offense was supposed to be unstoppable, and Manning — who finished the regular season by breaking Dan Marino’s record with 49 touchdowns to his credit — couldn’t find the end zone on Sunday.

He had a 121.1 passer rating this season, but delivered his worst performance of the season Sunday, failing to throw a touchdown pass for the first time all year as he ended the game with a 69.3 rating.

The Colts have dominated with the deep pass all year long, but against the Patriots Manning averaged a season-low 5.7 yards. His longest pass of the day was an 18-yarder to Marvin Harrison. As you watched the game Colts receivers were open down field but yet Manning was unable to get the ball down field or he never saw them. And what about Edgerrin James, who was held to 39 yards rushing?

Was it the weather conditions? Did Manning and his offense choke? Does New England truly have such a dominating defense?

The answer to the Colts’ problems Sunday is probably a combination of all three of those factors. But the big question is whether or not Manning will wind up being known for not making it to the big dance. And if he does will he win the big one?

His college record was very impressive during the years at Knoxville, and as a starter he was 39-5. He was 3-1 in bowl games, but couldn’t lead the Vols past Nebraska in the Orange Bowl his senior year, as Tennessee fell 47-17. In 1995 the Big Orange went 11-1, in 1996 they were 10-2, and during his senior year in ’97, they finished a respectable 11-2.

He finished second in the Heisman voting to Charles Woodson that year, and some Vol fans still have a bad taste in their mouth over that one.

Manning is without a doubt the best quarterback in the NFL and Tom Brady isn’t too bad as he works on his third Super Bowl. But if Manning can’t get his team to the Super Bowl and win it, then he may become the next Fran Tarkenton.

Tarkenton, who played his college ball at Georgia, was one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time. At the time of his retirement he owned every passing record — 3,686 pass completions, 47,003 passing yards and 342 touchdowns — but he never won a Super Bowl.

Could this be Manning’s future also? Lets hope not. I have to believe in the next two years Manning and the Colts will be wearing a ring.

Leave a Comment