Skip to content

Zavogiannis won?t prosecute murder case: Special prosecutor assigned due to conflict of interest

Zavogiannis won?t prosecute murder case: Special prosecutor assigned due to conflict of interest

ZAVOGIANNIS
A special prosecutor has been named in the case against a former daycare owner charged with murdering a 6-year-old child in her custody after the district attorney recused herself because of a potential conflict of interest.

The defendant, Sherry Mathis, remains free on bond awaiting trial on first-degree murder charges for the mysterious 2004 death of Cheyenne Delp, who was in her custody. No trial date has been set as the new prosecutor, Tory Johnson of Nashville, will confer with Circuit Court Judge Bart Stanley to set the case for trial.

Prosecutors maintain the child was the victim of abuse at the hands of Mathis. Specifically, forensic pathologists say it was strangulation, asphyxiation and possibly smothering which led to the child?s death. They also say they found numerous bruises on the girl?s body.

In her defense, Mathis, through her attorney, maintains the girl had medical and psychological problems and had suffered attacks before. Mathis maintains she tried to revive the girl when she suffered the fatal attack. She denies abusing the child.

The case was placed on hold more than a year ago during a battle over the admissibility of medical records belonging to the victim?s siblings who were also in Mathis? custody at the time of Delp?s death. The case was continued again up the results of the August elections where former DA Dale Potter was ousted from office by the new DA Lisa Zavogiannis.

Upon reviewing her case load after taking office in September, Zavogiannis said she realized she had earlier represented the children in question in a child services matter. Therefore, Zavogiannis said she feels there is a conflict of interest.

?I just didn?t think it would be appropriate to stay on the case,? Zavogiannis said. ?I want everything to go smoothly.?

While a trial date could be set soon, it was pointed out by sources close to the investigation that the evidence is technical and much of it medically based. That means it will likely take some time for the special prosecutor to get up to speed thereby delaying any trial until well into 2007, if that early.

Leave a Comment