Skip to content

Teacher, minister faces 9 sex counts: Prosecutors say longtime affair involved girl, 14

Teacher, minister faces 9 sex counts: Prosecutors say longtime affair involved girl, 14

McELROY
A Van Buren County teacher and minister has been indicted on nine felony counts for allegedly carrying on a sexual affair with a 14-year-old female student.

The defendant, Johnny Lee McElroy, 54, was indicted recently by the Van Buren County grand jury on nine counts of sexual battery by an authority figure. He remains held at Van Buren County Jail under $495,000 bond where he has been an inmate since his arrest this February.

His defense is exploring the possibility of asking for bond reduction, something which may come when he appears for arraignment before Judge Bart Stanley on Aug. 28 in Spencer. He faces three to six years in prison on each count.

The nine counts come from nine encounters lawmen say McElroy had with the girl during their extensive sexual affair. Investigators believe the affair occurred over a long period, with McElory grooming the victim for some time before the sexual contact began.

McElroy, who had been with the school system since 1998 and is also a Church of Christ preacher, was a high school teacher who first met his victim a few years back when he taught her in the sixth grade at Van Buren County Middle School. He was not her teacher at the time of the sexual affair. The victim is now 15.

Investigators say the sexual contact between the two happened in numerous places including his classroom during school hours, at the city park and in a moving vehicle.

Prosecutors have resisted comparisons between McElroy and imprisoned former Centertown teacher Pamela Rogers, now serving the balance of her eight-year sentence on similar charges, other than the obvious teacher/pupil scenario.

Prosecutors suggest McElroy could face a long prison sentence because of the emotional trauma the girl has suffered due to her long-term involvement with McElroy.

Leave a Comment