Skip to content

Slain preacher knew about financial scam, lawyer says

Slain preacher knew about financial scam, lawyer says

Judge McCraw Weber said he will likely rule this week on whether Mary Winkler is granted bond.
A small-town preacher whose wife is charged with killing him took part in accepting suspicious checks from Canada and Nigeria that were deposited in the family?s bank accounts, a defense lawyer said Thursday.

“As a family they were being conned,” lawyer Steve Farese said.

Matthew Winkler, 31, was killed with a shotgun in March at his Church of Christ parsonage in Selmer, 80 miles east of Memphis. His wife, Mary Winkler, 32, is charged with first-degree murder.

Mary Winkler, who was the family bookkeeper, told police she argued with her husband the night before the shooting about finances and other family matters.

Authorities say that argument came shortly after she was called by a Selmer-area bank with questions about unusual check deposits and money transfers.

A prosecution witness said at a bond hearing Friday that Mary Winkler put overseas checks totaling $17,500 in family accounts and then shifted deposits from bank to bank through “check kiting.”

Defense lawyers described their client as a victim of an overseas check scam, and Farese said Matthew Winkler was swindled, too.

“The information we have is that he was aware of the checks … and knew about where they were being deposited,” Farese said from his office in Mississippi near Memphis.

Farese said he did not know how the Winklers were conned or the details of the scheme but they got at least three checks, the first one in December, totaling more than $17,000 from sources abroad.

“They did get some money, but it turned out they were fraudulent checks,” he said.

The scheme was apparently similar, he said, to the so-called “Nigerian scam,” a long-running con focused on convincing victims to pay upfront fees for shares of a hidden fortune.

Victims often are contacted through the mail or the Internet and sometimes sent checks to deposit in their banks before forwarding cash or new checks elsewhere.

Such schemes have been so popular with con artists working out of Nigeria they also are called “419 scams,” named for a section of the Nigerian penal code.

The Winklers, with their three young daughters, were living on a tight budget, “just generally hand to mouth,” Farese said, “and those are the kinds of people most susceptible to these apparent windfalls.”

Leave a Comment