Skip to content

Tennessee among best in student testing programs

Tennessee is one of only 10 states to be granted full approval by federal officials for its testing of public school students under the No Child Left Behind Act.

Most states are failing to pass muster with the government over student testing and may lose federal education funding unless they improve quickly.

But Tennessee, Maryland, Oklahoma and West Virginia received full approval without any suggestions for improvement.

Six other states’ programs were also approved with recommendations for improvement. Four more are expected to be approved after they submit plans to correct problems with their programs.

But the U.S. Education Department says 34 states, the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico have major problems with the tests that were supposed to be in place in the just-ended school year. They will get federal approval only if they correct the problems in the coming year.

In addition, Nebraska and Maine had their testing systems rejected outright.

They all face the threat of losing from $40,000 to more than $1 million of the money they receive to administer the No Child Left Behind law. In most cases, the total would be less than $100,000; Nebraska and Maine could lose one-quarter of their dollars.

The money would go instead to school districts, skipping state governments altogether.

The report card of the states, released Thursday, is intended to get them to finish the job.

President Bush?s education law orders states to hold math and reading tests in the third- to eighth-grade, and once in high school. The deadline was the end of the 2005-06 school year.

Every state did have testing in the required grades. But many states still have significant problems, such as developing exams for disabled or limited-English students, or ensuring that tests are technically sound.

Assistant Education Secretary Ray Simon said states? overall performances were positive. Even the 36 jurisdictions whose approval remains pending probably will get the federal OK within a year, he said.

“I think maybe the scope of the work was just more broad, difficult and time-consuming than many of them thought,” Simon said Thursday. “I don’t think there was any attempt for them to sit back, do nothing and say, ‘Let’s see how much we can get away with.'”

States that have fallen short must submit a plan and a timeline for improvements. They may appeal their status, too. Those with continued problems could lose 10 percent to 25 percent of their federal administrative money.

Nebraska and Maine, the states most at odds with the department, face the maximum fine ? a one-fourth cut.

Jack Jennings, president of the independent Center on Education Policy, said withholding administrative money from states could be counterproductive. State education departments rely heavily on federal money to hire the staff that oversee testing.

“They will be weakening the very agencies they expect to carry out the law,” Jennings said.

Making the grade

Grades given by the Education Department for No Child Left Behind testing plans:

? Full approval: Maryland, Oklahoma, Tennessee, West Virginia.

? Full approval with recommendations for improvement: Arizona, Delaware, Indiana, North Carolina, South Carolina, Utah.

? Approval expected, which means states must submit a plan to fix problems but face no immediate threat of withheld money: Alaska, Connecticut, Louisiana, Massachusetts.

? Pending approval, which means states could lose federal administrative money if they don’t fix their problems based on a revised plan: Alabama, Arkansas, California, Colorado, District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Dakota, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Puerto Rico, Rhode Island, South Dakota, Texas, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, Wisconsin, Wyoming.

? Nonapproved, which means the plans were rejected and states may lose the maximum amount of administrative money: Maine and Nebraska.

Leave a Comment