Appeals court rules in favor of teacher in fainting incident
A teacher was not to blame for a student fainting after seeing a bloody first-aid video, an appeals court ruled in overturning a decision that awarded $32,000 in damages to the student.
Circuit Court Judge Dale Workman last year decided in favor of Brooke Rathnow, who sued for medical and future expenses after the incident in December 2003.
Rathnow told Bearden High School teacher Jennifer Allen she felt ill and wanted to get some fresh air as students watched a Red Cross video of an industrial accident in which a worker was gashed on his arm with a circular saw. Rathnow fainted outside the classroom and broke part of a tooth when she fell.
The Knox County school system appealed the lower-court ruling, which was struck down by the state Court of Appeals in an opinion filed Tuesday.
The court found the teacher could not have known the student was going to faint.
“We have reviewed the subject video, and we do not believe the scene that allegedly caused Ms. Rathnow to faint was sufficiently graphic or disturbing to place a reasonable person on notice that an individual viewing it would react as Ms. Rathnow did,” the court said.
Rathnow’s attorney, William S. Lockett Jr., said the family is “considering their options” before deciding whether to appeal to the state Supreme Court.
