Skip to content

In post-truth era, facts mean less

Facts aren’t what they used to be. In the old days, they were the meat and potatoes of an informed opinion. Today, they’re like toppings on a sundae. You sprinkle on the ones you like and leave the rest off. That way, you get something sweet and tasty, exactly to your personal preference.

I was reminded of this Wednesday as people responded on talk radio and online to the comprehensive evidence of Barry Bonds’ repeated, knowing use of illicit performance-enhancing drugs since 1998. Much of the evidence is laid out in a published excerpt from the upcoming book, “Game of Shadows,’ written by two Chronicle investigative reporters, Mark Fainaru-Wada and Lance Williams.

A representative comment from a sports Web site: “This is just a witch hunt trying to bring down an unhappy, grumpy, mean man that is about to be a baseball legend. People only like seeing nice people succeed (a la Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa).”

But it wasn’t just fans who dismissed the evidence. Two San Francisco talk-show hosts — former Mayor Willie Brown and comedian Will Durst — attacked the “so-called journalists’ who are trying to disrupt the Giants’ spring training (why else release the book NOW?) and who just want to ruin Bonds and are relying on the words of Bonds’ former mistress, a woman scorned and all that.

The Sports Illustrated writer they were interviewing on air Wednesday morning asked if either host had read the excerpt, which is published in Sports Illustrated this week, or looked at the authors’ detailed account of their exhaustive sourcing.

Well, no, they had not actually read the story. Just bits and pieces. Why use facts to determine the truth? They already had the truth: Bonds is a great but misunderstood player, and the writers are unscrupulous, lying jackals out to make a buck.

In our therapist couch of a country, all truth is personal. There is my truth and your truth, and those truths are not to be contradicted by facts. We believe what we want. And we don’t hold to account those who lie to us because the lies were “understandable”: Clinton lying about his affair, Bush lying about weapons of mass destruction, Bonds lying about taking steroids.

When former Labor Secretary Robert Reich was nailed for multiple inaccuracies and embellishments in his memoir, he proffered this defense: “I was absolutely true to my memory.’

It’s what author Ralph Keyes calls “The Post-Truth Era,’ the title of his 2004 book about the acceptability of lying in today’s culture.

“We always want to find a way to forgive and excuse deception engaged in by people we support,’ Keyes said by phone from his home in Ohio. “The whole concept of being held accountable has gotten so nibbled at that it’s barely visible.’

In Bonds’ case, not only are his supporters letting him off the hook, they’re shifting the blame to the reporters. People do all the time, and perhaps more than ever, when the wrongdoer happens to be somebody they support.

Bonds alone tainted his reputation and cheapened his accomplishments. He — not this book — has cast a shadow over spring training. You can’t read this excerpt and not conclude: He took steroids. He cheated. He lied. He betrayed the trust people had in him and in the game.

But I’m not sure deception and wrongdoing make much difference in the post-truth era. Journalists can uncover clear evidence of lying and cheating, and still the politicians get re-elected, the ballplayers get endorsements, the CEOs get bonuses and the celebrities get a slot on Oprah.

And when enough of us dismiss fact as fantasy, society loses its ability to reach intelligent conclusions and form reasonable opinions. What we have left are fluffy confections of our own invention, all self-indulgence and empty calories.

Joan Ryan is a columnist for the San Francisco Chronicle. Her e-mail is [email protected].

Leave a Comment