Skip to content

My Turn: Has Hollywood lost touch?

Call me old-fashioned, but it seems to me that Hollywood has gotten totally out of touch with mainstream Americans in recent years. This year?s Academy Awards, held two weeks ago, were a graphic demonstration of just how far left of center American movies have become.

For example, the Best Picture Oscar went to ?Crash? ? described as ?a portrait of simmering racial and cultural tension among blacks, whites, Hispanics, Asians and Arabs.? The other four nominated films included ?Good Night and Good Luck? ? which seemed to suggest the Cold War?s communist threat was largely a figment of American paranoid imagination; ?Brokeback Mountain? ? a paean to gay cowboys; ?Capote? ? a tribute to Truman Capote, poster boy for the effete, gay intellectual lifestyle; and ?Munich? ? wherein Palestinian terrorists were portrayed with more sympathy than their barbarous acts deserved.

In the interest of full disclosure, I must admit my familiarity with all these films is not based on first-hand viewings of them. Instead, my impressions come from various media accounts, including excerpts of the films. Still, I?ve read and seen enough to know that the film industry?s cultural elites who brought these movies to life won?t be getting any of my money.

Apparently I?m not alone in avoiding the orgy of arrogance and self-absorption typified by this year?s Academy Awards. According to movie industry estimates, this year?s five Best Picture nominees grossed about $227 million, barely one-third of the nominees? gross in previous years. This could, of course, be attributable to other factors, such as the general decline in movie attendance due to television and other viewing alternatives to the high costs of a night out at the movies. However, other, less elitist movies have done better at the box office, which suggests that many movie-goers prefer being entertained to being offended when parting with their hard-earned money.

By the way, the TV audience for the Academy Awards continues to dwindle, too. According to media industry estimates, only about 39 million viewers watched the 2006 Oscar Awards, down from about 42 million viewers in 2005, and about 55 million in 1998.

As a songwriter, for more fun than profit lately, I was stunned to learn that this year?s Oscar for best original song went to ?It?s Hard Out Here for a Pimp.? How anyone, black, brown, or white, with a brain still functioning, could call that song worthy of Oscar consideration is beyond me.

From ?Best Picture? to ?Best Song,? the 2006 Oscar nominations and awards seemed to me to be more about elite, leftist propaganda than about mass entertainment. I hope this surrender by Academy voters to ?message movies? is a temporary setback. Judging from the smugness of George Clooney and others of his ilk in the Hollywood entertainment community, I fear it may become a trend.

One bright shining exception to all this came when our fellow Tennessean, Reese Witherspoon, won the ?Best Actress? Oscar for her role as June Carter in ?Walk the Line.? Her gracious acceptance speech lent dignity to what otherwise seemed often to be a celebration of indignity.

Thomas B. Vaughn is a professor at Motlow College and co-host of the WCPI radio show ?Viewpoints.?

Leave a Comment