Lawmakers make push to crack down on illegal immigration
JOELTON — State Rep. Beth Harwell said the federal government hasn’t done enough to control illegal immigration, so state lawmakers are deciding to act.
More than a dozen immigration bills have been introduced in the Tennessee General Assembly this session, and some lawmakers say their constituents consider it a top issue.
“People just believe that our federal immigration laws are unrealistic,” said Harwell, a Nashville Republican who chairs a GOP task force on immigration issues.
“They know we should admit more low-skill workers. No one doubts that there’s a job market for them,” she said. “But they should not be here illegally.”
The U.S. House passed a bill in December that makes it a felony for illegal immigrants to be in the United States and, imposes new penalties on employers who hire them, but the Senate is still debating the issue.
In Tennessee, some proposals would also punish businesses that employ illegal workers, and others would make it harder for illegal immigrants to get driver’s certificates and public services.
Many illegal workers are part of the tide of Hispanic immigration rolling across the Southeast. The Hispanic population in Tennessee is about three times what it was a decade ago.
State Rep. Gary Moore, D-Joelton, has filed three bills addressing illegal immigration because a survey of his constituents last year showed that immigration was the second-most common concern, behind taxes, but ahead of ethics.
“What is driving that, quite honestly, I don’t know,” said Moore, whose district is in rural northwest Davidson County.
Some of Moore’s constituents have answers. Diners at Nick’s Bar-B-Q in Joelton recently complained about illegal immigrants getting public benefits.
Bill Bernard said he was in the grocery store and saw someone he suspected was not a U.S. citizen paying with a government food card. “How did she get that? How do you tell if somebody is legal or not by looking at them?”
Others criticized the state decision to issue driving certificates to illegal immigrants. “That was the stupidest bill,” John Ruff said.
One Moore bill would make it a felony for anyone to knowingly employ illegal immigrants. Another would have the state Department of Safety enforce some federal immigration laws. A third would ban companies from doing business with the state for a year if they are found to employ illegal immigrants.
Businesses or individuals who employ workers in the country illegally would be subject to a fine of up to $10,000 under Moore’s proposal.
State troopers arresting motorists could also charge them with violation of federal immigration laws, Moore said.
Last year state legislatures saw hundreds of bills on immigration policy. The National Conference of State Legislatures reported more than 300 illegal immigration bills filed last year, with 47 of them being passed.
The number of illegal immigrants in the United States has grown to as high as 12 million, according to a new estimate released this month. The Pew Hispanic Center report estimated that undocumented workers fill one out of every four agricultural jobs, 17 percent of all office and house cleaning positions, 14 percent of construction jobs, and 12 percent of those who work in food preparation.
Robert Chavez of the Tennessee Hispanic Chamber of Commerce said the federal government needs to solve the illegal immigration problem, and the best way is to make it easier for people to enter the country legally, he said.
“The only correct way is to allow people to document themselves at the border,” Chavez said. “We certainly would support the documentation of workers for a three-year period and then they have to renew it.”
It could be a popular issue in an election year, but leaders in the General Assembly are reluctant to handicap the chances of various immigration bills. Senate Republican Leader Ron Ramsey said the bill most likely to pass is one to shut down the driving certificates program, which is now on hold.
A statewide poll conducted by Middle Tennessee State University shows state residents evenly split on the question of whether they believe illegal immigrants take jobs from legal residents, or are doing jobs most legal residents would not want.
J.L. Simpson, another diner at Nick’s in Joelton, said penalizing businesses that hire illegal workers could have an economic impact, he said.
“If you do that, 98 percent of the highway construction will stop,” Simpson said.
