Appeals court rules private school can sue TSSAA over divisions
A three-judge panel of the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati reversed a lower court decision, sending the case of Brentwood Academy v. the Tennessee Secondary Schools Athletic Association back to U.S. District Court for a third time.
The case, which has been before the U.S. Supreme Court, was first filed in 1998 over sanctions TSSAA issued against Brentwood Academy in a recruiting dispute.
Brentwood Academy’s lawsuit alleges the TSSAA, whose membership is mostly public schools, restricts competition by placing most private schools in a separate division.
All public schools in Tennessee participate in Division 1 sports, while most private schools are grouped in Division 2. The ruling comes during the Division 1 basketball tournament in Murfreesboro.
TSSAA executive director Ronnie Carter said he was disappointed with the ruling.
H. Lee Barfield, lawyer for the school, said the situation amounts to a boycott of private schools by public schools and the TSSAA, which is illegal under federal antitrust law.
“If a group of competitors gets together and agrees to boycott another group, that’s grounds for action,” Barfield said.
Carter said schools that offer financial aid are in Division 2, though private schools that don’t offer aid can choose to participate in Division 2. Public schools can also opt to participate in Division 2, though none do, he said.
The TSSAA penalizes private schools for offering financial aid for students, including student-athletes who need it, said James F. Blumstein, a Vanderbilt law professor who represents Brentwood Academy in the case.
Barfield called public schools “full tuition” schools and that to segregate private schools because they offer financial aid amounts to illegal price-fixing. Private schools that do not offer financial aid compete in Division 1.
“There is a perception that need-based financial aid can be an unleveling of the playing field,” Carter said. “There’s opinions on both sides.”
The TSSAA said Brentwood Academy broke the rules in 1997 when it sent spring-practice letters to a dozen students who had already signed contracts to attend the school the next fall. It fined the school $3,000 and put it on four years’ probation.
The case began in U.S. District Court in Nashville after the school lost two appeals before the TSSAA.
The case also has been argued before the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals and the U.S. Supreme Court, which found the TSSAA functioned as a “state actor” because it oversees secondary school athletics across the state, and therefore could be sued on constitutional grounds.
In its ruling Friday, the appeals court upheld the lower court ruling that the TSSAA violated the school’s First Amendment rights to send the letter to recruits. But the court reversed the lower court’s ruling that the TSSAA executive director is not entitled to individual immunity in the lawsuit.
