Skip to content

Appeals court allows ‘Choose Life’ license plates in Tennessee

NASHVILLE — A federal appeals court Friday allowed Tennessee to offer anti-abortion license plates bearing the message “Choose Life.”

A three-judge panel of the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati overturned a lower-court ruling that said the tag illegally promoted only one side of the abortion debate.

“Although this exercise of government one-sidedness with respect to a very contentious political issue may be ill-advised, we are unable to conclude that the Tennessee statute contravenes the First Amendment,” Judge John M. Rogers said in a 2-1 ruling.

Rogers said the First Amendment does not prohibit the government from using private volunteers to put out its message — even if that message is controversial or politically divisive.

An anti-abortion group, Tennessee Right to Life, declared victory.

“It’s a validation of our position all along that the Legislature had the authority to authorize a plate that favors normal childbirth over the practice of abortion,” said Brian Harris, the group’s president.

In a dissenting opinion, Judge Boyce F. Martin Jr. said the specialty plate program is unconstitutional because it discriminates against one side in the abortion debate.

An attempt to create a “Choose Choice” tag failed in the Legislature in 2002.

Federal appeals courts have been divided over whether such license plate programs are constitutional. Last year the U.S. Supreme Court let stand a lower-court ruling that said similar South Carolina license plates violated the First Amendment.

Drivers will be able to pay an extra fee in Tennessee for the “Choose Life” plate, and some of the proceeds will go to New Life Resources, an anti-abortion group.

Tennessee is the 13th state to offer “Choose Life” plates. The others are Alabama, Arkansas, Connecticut, Florida, Hawaii, Louisiana, Maryland, Mississippi, Montana, Ohio, Oklahoma and South Dakota. Most states donate proceeds to adoption groups, but Alabama, Hawaii, Maryland and Montana donate at least some of the money to anti-abortion groups.

Tennessee has more than 120 specialty plates, most of them saluting uncontroversial subjects such as the Tennessee Titans football team, the Smoky Mountains and the Tennessee Walking Horse.

Gov. Phil Bredesen let the anti-abortion license plates measure become law but declined to sign it, and he urged lawmakers to develop a new approach to deciding which causes would benefit from the sale of specialty plates.

The state of Tennessee did not appeal the district court ruling that outlawed the plates. Instead, New Life Resources intervened and took the case to the 6th Circuit.

In his dissent, Martin mocked the notion that Tennessee’s specialty plates were promoting a government message. He called the license plates “a forum for private speakers” that should be protected by the First Amendment.

If the license plate program were promoting a government message, then the state wouldn’t offer a car tag saluting Tennessee’s archrival in football, the University of Florida and its alligator mascot, Martin said.

He also dismissed the majority’s fears that the state would have to offer license plates to the Ku Klux Klan or the American Nazi Party if it could not discriminate against viewpoints.

Martin noted that Tennessee already has a license plate for the Sons of Confederate Veterans, and many people consider the Confederate battle emblem offensive.

“If the KKK and Nazi Party are able to pull together 1,000 proud, dues-paying members, who wish to display such license plates on their cars … they are entitled to do so the same as the Sons of Confederate Veterans, Penn State Alumni, antique aficionados and members of pro-life and pro-choice organizations,” he wrote.

Hedy Weinberg, executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Tennessee, a plaintiff in the case, said the ruling “fails to protect free speech and permits viewpoint discrimination.”

Weinberg said the ACLU hasn’t decided whether it will appeal to the Supreme Court.

“We don’t think it’s in the state’s best interest to be promoting such a one-sided view,” said Keri Adams, vice president of community for Planned Parenthood of Middle and East Tennessee, another plaintiff.

Leave a Comment