Skip to content

Wilson Co. parents convicted of reduced neglect charges

LEBANON, Tenn. Copyright 2006 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. — A father and stepmother were found guilty Monday of reduced neglect charges in the treatment of their malnourished teenage son, who weighed 50 pounds when he was taken into state custody.

James C. and Christie Osborne each faced a charge of aggravated child neglect, but the jury convicted each on a reduced charge of attempted aggravated child neglect, carrying a possible prison sentence of three to six years.

The father originally faced an additional charge of aggravated assault by failure to protect, but the jury instead convicted him on one count of child neglect, with a possible sentence of just under a year.

Jurors deliberated for about five hours Monday, and asked for a definition of “serious bodily injury” but the judge said he could not provide more than that description.

“Basically, the jury had difficulty with finding there was serious bodily injury,” Assistant District Attorney General Jason Lawson said after the verdict.

The two were charged after the state Department of Children’s Services investigated their home and took Joshua Osborne, then 15 years old, into protective custody in 2004.

Joshua testified last week that he had to escape chains holding him in bed in order to find food — sometimes taking it from his home and sometimes stealing it from stores. The couple didn’t testify.

Defense attorneys argued that the boy, who received a heart transplant when he was 2 weeks old, was on a restricted diet under doctors’ orders and that he was restrained because he was violent and had tried to kill his mother.

Dr. Debra Dodd, who has treated Joshua since his birth, told jurors he was skinny but not in medical distress when state officials sent him to the hospital in 2004. She said none of his medications had been changed since then, only his diet.

“I think it rules out all the other explanations for his condition except malnutrition,” Dodd testified.

Joshua has doubled his weight since he was taken into custody and testified that he now weighs 100 pounds.

Adam Parrish, attorney for Christie Osborne, said Joshua has admitted killing the family cat, trying to sneak out of the house to steal things from Wal-Mart and threatening to kill his baby sister and his parents.

“There’s no question restraint was used on Josh,” Parrish told the jury in closing statements. “Whether or not that was appropriate in the light of all things, that’s for you, not me, to decide.”

District Attorney Howard Lee Chambers told jurors that Joshua was forced to steal in order to stay alive.

“When you’re deprived of food the way they deprived him of food, and you have to steal to satisfy the basic need of hunger, it’s easy to steal other things,” Chambers said.

The defense attorneys said that soup and water were only part of a restricted diet recommended by doctors. Joshua underwent a heart transplant when he was 2 weeks old.

The teenager also was fed grits, oatmeal, cantaloupe and toast, defense attorneys told the jury.

After he was removed from the home, Joshua spent three weeks at Vanderbilt University’s Monroe Carell Jr. Children’s Hospital recovering from malnutrition, dehydration and a dangerously low level of minerals in his bloodstream, records show.

Jurors have seen the chains that were used on the boy, and some of them cried when he entered the courtroom last week for his testimony. Others waved and smiled at him.

Sentencing was set for May 9. Christie Osborne is currently in custody on a parole violation.

Leave a Comment