Skip to content

Christian fish tag could re-ignite battle over specialty plates

NASHVILLE — A proposal to put the Christian fish symbol on Tennessee license plates could re-ignite a debate over the proliferation of specialty tags in the state.

The simple line drawing of a fish, which many Christians already put on their bumpers, would appear on an official state license plate for a fee, with the extra money going to a cause or charity.

The Republican lawmaker who proposed the fish plates, Donna Rowland of Murfreesboro, hasn’t yet identified the cause or charity that would benefit from the tag.

Tennessee already has more than 120 of the specialty plates. The most popular salutes the Tennessee Titans football team, but there are others for Korean War veterans, the Smokies and the Tennessee Walking Horse.

If approved by the General Assembly, the fish design would be the state’s first explicitly religious license plate. The sponsor said that shouldn’t be a problem.

“It’s an individual choice to pick a license plate,” Rowland said. “It’s not physically offensive or hate-driven or any way.”

Sen. Steve Cohen, who was one of the original proponents of the specialty license plate program, said putting a Christian symbol on state tags amounts to the state sanctioning religion.

“Whenever you have the state getting involved with religion, it hurts religion and it hurts government,” said the Memphis Democrat.

In 2004, a federal judge rejected Tennessee’s “Choose Life” license plate, saying it was unconstitutional because it promotes only one side of the abortion debate. That decision is now on appeal, and the federal courts are divided over whether license plate programs in a dozen states are constitutional.

Tennessee Gov. Phil Bredesen has asked lawmakers to control the expansion of the car tag program, and he discouraged them from creating plates that get “into a constitutionally suspect territory.”

But lawmakers are reluctant to reel in the program — it’s popular, and it raises money for good causes.

Legislators have introduced more than 40 proposals for specialty tags this year, including plates for military service, state wildflowers, the Memphis Zoo and the Tennessee cave salamander.

Tennessee issued more than 330,000 specialty plates in the budget year ending June 30, collecting $8.5 million split between various causes, the state’s arts commission, the highway fund and general revenues.

House Transportation Chairman Phillip Pinion, a main supporter of the “Choose Life” plate, said he wouldn’t work to halt the Christian fish plates this session.

“I don’t know how we can stop it,” the Union City Democrat said. “If it came through my committee, I’m sure we’d pass it.”

Pinion said he understands that the governor wants to restrict the growth in specialty tags, but feels it would be unfair to legitimate causes to be excluded from the program.

“I’ve got mixed emotions about it,” he said. “I think we’ve got too many of them, and it’s getting harder for the Highway Patrol to follow. But where do we stop?”

The state’s specialty plates program began two decades ago as a way to help fund the Tennessee Arts Commission, which receives 40 percent of the additional $35 the plates cost.

Cohen said another court battle could lead to the whole specialty plate program being killed off.

“They are risking the entire license plate program, which could affect education, cultural and charitable opportunities for people thought the state.”

Supporters of the plate program say current restrictions requiring 1,000 people to pledge $35 each before a new plate is issued keep frivolous or unpopular plates off the street.

An antidote to the booming demand for specialty plates might be the recent introduction of a better-designed standard plate.

The new design features green Tennessee hills and replaces the 2001 plate that showed the sun rising over a state map with the now-abandoned slogan, “Tennessee sounds good to me.”

In choosing the new design, “the governor was interested in having a plate that Tennesseans would actually want to put on their car,” said Will Pinkston, a former Bredesen official who was involved in the new plate selection process.

“I think a number of people were concerned about the financial effect that an appealing plate could have on a specialty plate program,” said Pinkston. “Until this point, the only appealing plate you could get was specialty plates.”

Tennessee’s specialty plates
Tennessee currently offers more than 120 specialty license plates. They include:

CLUBS/GROUPS

Alpha Kappa Alpha

Alpha Phi Alpha

Delta Sigma Theta

Ducks Unlimited

Fraternal Order of Police (FOP)

International Association of Firefighters

Kappa Alpha Psi

Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD)

Masons

Omega Psi Phi

Phi Beta Sigma

TN Police Benevolent Association

Zeta Phi Beta

MILITARY/VETERANS

Bosnia Veteran

Bronze Star Meritorious

Bronze Star Valor

Desert Storm Veteran

Disabled Veteran

Enemy Evadee

Handicapped Veteran

Honorably Discharged Veteran

Korean War Veteran

Legion of Valor

Medal of Honor

Military

National Guard

Pearl Harbor Survivor

Prisoner of War

Purple Heart

Silver Star

Vietnam Veteran

WWII Veteran

COLLEGIATE PLATES

Alabama

APSU

Arkansas

Auburn

Belmont

Bryan College

Carson-Newman

Clemson University

Cumberland

ETSU

Florida State

Freed-Hardeman

Georgia Tech

Indiana

Kentucky

King College

Lane College

Lee University

LeMoyne-Owen

Lipscomb University

Maryville College

Memphis

Milligan College

Mississippi State

MTSU

Penn State

Purdue University

Rhodes

TN Tech

TN Wesleyan

Trevecca Nazarene

TSU

Tusculum College

Union

University of Florida

University of Mississippi

University of the South

UT-Chattanooga

UT-Generic

UT-Knoxville UT-Martin

Vanderbilt

Virginia Tech

MISCELLANEOUS

American Eagle Foundation

Agriculture

Animal Friendly

Antique

Automobile/Motor Home

Children First

Consular

East Tennessee Children’s Hospital

Environmental

Fish and Wildlife Species-Bear

Fish and Wildlife Species-Turkey

Friends of the Smokies

Helping Schools

Le Bonheur Children’s Medical Center

Personalized

Prince Hall Masons

Radnor Lake

Sons of Confederate Veterans

Sportsman

St. Jude

TN Arts Commission-Cat

TN Arts Commission-Fish

Tn Arts Commission-Rainbow

Tennessee Walking Horse

U.S. Olympic

UT Football Championship

Lady Vols Championship

Vanderbilt Children’s Hospital

Watchable Wildlife

EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT

Amateur Radio

Emergency

Emergency Trauma Physician

Firefighter

Rescue Squad

PROFESSIONAL SPORTS

Tennessee Titans

DISABLED PLATES

Disabled Person

Hearing Impaired

——

Source: http://www.state.tn.us/safety/plates.html

——

On the Net:

Tennessee’s specialty plate program: http://www.state.tn.us/safety/plates.html#club

Leave a Comment