Dumb questions, dumb answers
Every generation seems to need its own universal Theory of Everything, reducing all human experience to a handful of easily memorized slogans. What with astrology, Marxism and Freudian psychoanalysis in eclipse and Rush Limbaugh on drugs, the latest psuedo-scientific fad to capture the attention of the credulous appears to be evolutionary psychology.
Anyhow, here’s the latest pronouncement from an official-looking Web site called Neuropolitics.org: Liberals like cats, while conservatives prefer dogs. Accompanied by lots of bar graphs, statistical summaries, brain-scan photos and portentous rhetorical questions, this would come as an unpleasant surprise to the three dogs snoring on my office couch as I write — as I normally lean Democratic.
Neuropolitics.org presents plenty of data suggesting biological origins to political differences. According to the numbers, conservatives also eat a lot more beef than liberals, prefer bold colors such as red and dark blue to the dark green favored by liberal men, and are more likely to be athletic.
Neuropolitics.org also features an online quiz asking such puzzlers as whether Hillary Clinton or Rudy Giuliani has a better sense of humor, or, given no other choices, you’d prefer communism, fascism or anarchy. I chose anarchy: Fewer committee meetings, no uniforms. They also asked how often I perform the marital act, and which of three actresses — black, white or Asian — I thought hottest. I chose the one wearing the least makeup.
In return I received a brief neurological profile suggesting an “enhanced dopamine level in your visual cortex” and “an elevation in activity in your right amygdala,” whatever that means. Supposedly, my “cognitive style is balanced between … left and right hemispheres,” which I took as a tribute to the perfect blend of thought and feeling readers no doubt recognize as the hallmark of this column.
But back to the big issue. Supposedly, “very liberal” women prefer cats to dogs by a margin of 60 percent to 38 percent, while “very conservative” men favor dogs almost equally. “So what is driving the conservative preference for dogs over cats?” the scientists wonder.
“Is it the dog’s pack-oriented nature and prominent submissive behaviors? Could this be an indicator of the conservative’s stronger propensity to organize into pack-like social structures? Conversely, what is driving the liberal’s preference for cats? Does the liberal have a stronger aversion to pack-like hierarchical organizations and an attraction to feline-like territorial-based social organization?”
Sorry, but this is nonsense. Blame my balanced cerebral hemispheres, but I’ve always felt very strongly both ways. People are always asking my wife and me if we’re dog people or cat people. The answer is both. (I’d probably have horses living in the house if the floors would bear their weight.) But we also see our four-legged friends as animals, not anthropomorphic projections in fur coats.
Politics, however, has nothing to do with it. Scientifically speaking, “liberal” and “conservative” are amorphous, constantly shifting terms that are close to meaningless. At the moment, more Democrats are women living in cities where dogs are harder to keep. If the numbers gathered by the bean-counters at Neuropolitics.org mean anything, that’s basically all they mean.
As a carnivorous, dog-loving, sports-crazed cat-fancier, I beg to differ.
Arkansas Democrat-Gazette columnist Gene Lyons can be reached by e-mail at [email protected].
