Skip to content

Taking A Stand: Dynamic of a jury difficult to gauge

I?ve gotten good at reading juries over the years, but it?s just like reading an election. While you may have a good idea the outcome, once in a while they?ll fool you.

I?ve been reminded of the interesting animal which a jury is during my time in Spencer this week listening to the Jeri Bryant murder trial. During my 16 years at the paper I?ve had many occasions to watch jurors during an array of trials ranging from drunk driving to murder. However, this is the first time I?ve seen a Spencer jury.

I?ve seen juries in Warren, Cumberland and Putnam counties during murder trials and they?re basically the same in their dynamic. I?ve also talked to jurors who have served on these cases to get a background on how they arrived at their decisions.

However, Van Buren County is a much smaller county where everyone literally knows everyone else, so it?s hard to know what connections the 13-man, two-woman jury has within the community with the participants in the case.

Does what you know before you hear the evidence make a difference? Much to the chagrin of attorneys, yes it does. Frankly, unless it is a slam dunk case where there are confessions and other evidence to support the confession, there?s a lot that goes into getting a verdict.

First, and foremost, the law has never stopped a jury from doing what it sees fit. I?ve seem many cases where jurors compromise on a verdict despite the fact their decision really didn?t fit the crime, law or evidence. Instead, jurors did a little plea negotiation of their own in the jury room, agreeing while the defendant wasn?t guilty of the top charge, he or she should be found guilty of something.

I think more than anything, the dynamic of 12 people in a jury room tends to bring about a feeling of fairplay. While a tribunal may not find enough to overcome reasonable doubt and convict on a top charge, they may find enough evidence to not feel good about just letting the defendant walk totally free.

This is where the negotiated settlements occur. They allow jurors to rest a little easier after the verdict, since I?m convinced most jurors I?ve seen take their job as jurors very seriously. I really believe jurors, in most trials, take great pains to get it right.

The very liberal jury instruction law nowadays, which requires the court to add a lesser included offense of ?an attempt? to almost every crime, makes it even easier to compromise down to a negotiated verdict. I?m seeing more and more of that lately, since these are the days of ?CSI? and ?Law & Order? on TV everyday, it?s hard to totally satisfy a juror?s appetite for direct evidence. Therefore, we get lesser verdicts where a case isn?t a slam dunk.

How do you read a jury? The best way is to become the jury. Looking at them this week, it was obvious that when I?m bored, they?re bored, judging from body language. When they?re interested, I?m interested, as evidenced by both me and jurors taking notes at certain high points.

However, the big difference is the group dynamic. How will a jury categorize evidence it has heard? One thing unimportant to one juror could be significant to another. In addition, what prior knowledge will they bring that wasn?t heard in the courtroom, and what biases could the jurors have? Also, who will be the leader? A foreman can swing a verdict if he is an alpha male.

While I can surmise, and I?ve been pretty good at guessing verdicts, there?s really no way to consistently predict what happens when the jury door closes.

Duane Sherrill is a reporter for the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].

Leave a Comment