My Turn: Hope for best, brace for worst
As of this writing, Iraq is teetering on the brink of outright civil war.
The current crisis was triggered by the Feb. 22 bombing of a revered Shiite shrine in the mostly Sunni city of Samarra, north of Baghdad.
Will Iraq pull back from the brink of civil war or plunge headlong into the abyss of internecine conflict? As much as we hope for the former, we need to prepare for the latter.
Nearly three years after the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq that toppled the tyranny of Saddam Hussein, recent events in Iraq do not inspire confidence in the ability of current Iraqi leaders. After two elections and a referendum on their constitution, these Iraqi leaders have yet to form anything resembling a coherent coalition that can govern that war-torn country.
This apparent inability or unwillingness to put aside partisan differences, sectarian and secular, could spell disaster for the future of Iraq. The key to rising above these rivalries, for the greater good of the Iraqi people, is unified, disciplined, principled, visionary leadership.
In my view, the first priority should be to establish a unified government that reflects the will of the Iraqi people, as expressed in the elections that saw them turn out in droves, despite all the dangers that we can only imagine.
Second, the new Iraqi government needs to move quickly to provide some measure of security and stability to a country that is sorely lacking both. This will not be easy, but it must be done. As George Will has aptly noted, ?Iraq barely has a government. A defining characteristic of a government is that it has a monopoly on the legitimate exercise of violence. That attribute is incompatible with the existence of private militias of the sort that maraud in Iraq.?
I agree with Mr. Will?s trenchant comments. Until the Iraqi people ? Shiites, Sunnis, and Kurds ? see their national government as the legitimate source of their security and stability, they are likely to fall back on their tribal instincts to protect themselves. In turn, that can only lead to further carnage and chaos.
Meanwhile, U.S. policy-makers need to continue to hope for the best and to prepare for the worst in Iraq. We have gone the extra mile in Iraq for nearly three years now. Along the way, we liberated the Iraqis from the ?Baghdad Butcher? and his rapacious regime. Then, we provided much of the impetus and resources to help the Iraqi people on their way to their own form of self-determination.
Now, it seems to me, Iraqi leaders need to understand that our commitment of American blood and treasure to the future of a viable Iraq is not open-ended.
Nor is our patience infinite.
The best outcome in Iraq will allow us to withdraw our forces in an orderly way, based on the demonstrated ability of the Iraqi military to provide security and stability for their own country. The worst will require us to withdraw under hostile conditions. Either way, we need contingency plans in place, ready to implement.
Thomas B. Vaughn is a professor at Motlow College an co-host of the radio show ?Viewpoints,? which airs on 91.3 FM.
