Bill would cut food tax in half and raise cigarette tax

Greg Sibbett

Greg Sibbett
Tennesseans for Fair Taxation and other groups working to end the state’s tax on food at statewide news conferences said Tennessee has the nation’s highest average food tax at 8.4 percent and one of the lowest cigarette taxes at 20 cents a pack.
The proposed legislation would cut the state food tax from 6 to 3 percent. Local government add-ons of up to 2.75 percent would not be affected.
Revenue to pay for the food tax cut would come from a 43 cents-a-pack increase in the cigarette tax, along with increases of one penny a pack each year over 10 years to ensure funds to pay for the food tax cut despite a decline in smoking and other trends.
In addition to making it harder for working Tennesseans to keep meals on the table, advocates say a high food tax hurts Tennessee grocers in border communities by driving shoppers over the state line.
“It’s (proposed bill) a shift of the tax burden. It’s revenue-neutral,” Rep. Gary Odom, D-Nashville and lead House sponsor of the bill, said at a news conference at the Capitol on Thursday morning. “I think it’s good health policy. I think it’s good tax policy.”
Rep. Joey Hensley, R-Hohenwald, who is also a doctor and a bill sponsor, said he’s seen firsthand the damaging effects of smoking and believes raising the cigarette tax would decrease the practice. If approved, the legislation would take effect July 1.
Advocates for the poor, such as the anti-hunger group MANNA in Nashville, are also behind the bill to cut the tax on food, which accounted for about $443 million, or 4.6 percent of all state taxes collected by the state in fiscal 2005.
A report by Tennesseans for Fair Taxation shows average sales taxes on food in states that border Tennessee range from no tax in Kentucky to 8 percent in both Alabama and Arkansas.
Gov. Phil Bredesen and other state leaders say there’s no reason to change the tax system.
“Any tax system that you have has good things and bad things about it, and it drives behavior,” Bredesen said in speech to business leaders on Wednesday. “There’s good things and bad things about income taxes and good things and bad things about sales taxes.
“We’ve committed to a sales tax or consumption tax approach in our state here,” he said. “My approach on this has been that it’s clear that this is what people prefer. Let’s live with that. Let’s show what we can do and go forward.”
Finance Commissioner Dave Goetz on Thursday said he is skeptical of a plan that would replace a steady revenue stream with a tax on the declining sales of cigarettes.
The state’s tax on cigarettes accounted for $121.2 million in fiscal 2005 compared to $119.5 million in fiscal 2004.
Tennessee’s annual tobacco crop, which shrank from about $300 million to about $200 million in the 1990s, now hovers around $90 million.
Lower demand from cigarette companies and foreign competition have contributed to the decreased production numbers, according to the state agricultural officials.
House Speaker Jimmy Naifeh said he’s not convinced the state can make up the tax on food with the cigarette tax.
“We all would like to take the sales tax off food, but I believe we’re going to have to have a better source of revenue than depending on the cigarette tax to cover the lost revenue,” he said.
“I’m just not sure that we could tax cigarettes enough and that it would remain a stable, recurring revenue source to make up for what we would lose in groceries.”
